News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A.I. ‘Bias’ Doesn’t Mean What Journalists Say It Means by skybrian on Sunday September 03, 2017 @12:38PM (#15162344)
Remember that these algorithms are attempting to predict the future based on past results. What the author calls a "true fact about reality" is a fact about the present or past. We then use this understanding of the past to try to predict the future. But as they say in finance, past performance is no guarantee of future results.

The whole idea behind "debiasing" is to avoid writing people off based on history of their group. Yes, taking chances on people who haven't done anything yet can cost money and a profit-maximizing algorithm will sometimes automatically avoid the risk by reproducing biases.

And that's why the algorithm designers need to watch over the algorithm and make sure it's not writing people off based on inferring the group they're in. As a society we've decided that giving people a chance to defy the historical odds of their group is worth the cost. Maintaining the status quo may be profit-maximizing but profit isn't actually the only goal. (Any more than paperclip-maximizing is.)

On the other hand these inferences can often be used in better ways. For example, colleges can identify "at risk" students and make sure they get extra help.

Re:A.I. ‘Bias’ Doesn’t Mean What Journalists Say It Means by carlmr on Monday September 04, 2017 @10:39AM (#15168491)
>On the other hand these inferences can often be used in better ways. For example, colleges can identify "at risk" students and make sure they get extra help.

I like that last sentiment. We shouldn't lie to ourselves about the truth, but we should use it to help make the situation better for society as a whole, not to discriminate against certain groups.