News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Where will artificial general intelligence come from? by mythrwy on Saturday September 02, 2017 @12:31PM (#15156845)
Background: Some guy on the Internet with an unrelated Bachelors degree he didn't study that hard for and has picked up a little Python and Javascript somewhere along the way.

I know of no biological forms that have evolved wheels. But wheels have turned out to be a hell of a lot faster than fins or legs. I see no reason "intelligence" has to follow the pathways or limitations of biology or neurology at all. Although certainly it may be a place to look for some ideas.

Re:Where will artificial general intelligence come from? by Chathamization on Saturday September 02, 2017 @03:10PM (#15157682)
> I know of no biological forms that have evolved wheels. But wheels have turned out to be a hell of a lot faster than fins or legs.

On certain terrain. And much slower - sometimes useless - on others. Wheels aren't simply better legs, they're a different way of moving, with its own benefits and drawbacks.

Likewise, if we're talking about computational ability, we already have things that are faster than the human brain in certain areas (say, numerical computation). When we talk about AGI, we're talking about human-like intelligence (at least to a certain degree).

So we already have the wheel, but now we want to develop something that does what the leg does. Now, maybe that doesn't have to be an actual leg, but that's usually what people usually end up with when they try to find something that will have a similar functionality as a leg.

Re:Where will artificial general intelligence come from? by MarkMc on Saturday September 02, 2017 @02:22PM (#15157423)
I would also point to heavier-than-air flight. For thousands of years people tried to mimic flapping wings of birds, but in the end it was the unnatural propellor and fixed wing design that gave us flight.
Re:Where will artificial general intelligence come from? by serf on Saturday September 02, 2017 @06:53PM (#15158664)
Fixed-wing flight isn't unknown to the natural world.[0]

Flagella use propeller motion for propulsion.[1]

Lots of animals use jets.[2]

I'd consider the combustion engine to be the most novel 'human' design with regards to aircraft propulsion -- or the way we achieve jet propulsion; that's pretty unique.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_soaring_birds

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flagellum

[2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jet_propulsion

Re:Where will artificial general intelligence come from? by hutzlibu on Sunday September 03, 2017 @07:28AM (#15160889)
... and a new energy source, the combustion engine.
Re:Where will artificial general intelligence come from? by viewtransform on Saturday September 02, 2017 @04:34PM (#15158061)
Not a wheel but a rotary motor: topologically the same. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flagellum
Re:Where will artificial general intelligence come from? by hatsunearu on Sunday September 03, 2017 @10:43AM (#15161651)
If you consider rotary motion as wheels, there are some bacteria that have flagella that rotate to propel itself, complete with molecular bearings.

That said, biological evolution tends to get stuck on local maxima very easily (see convergent evolution of eyeballs), and wheels are kind of hard to evolve because of the difficulty of making large bearings biologically.

Not to mention wheels kind of suck unless you're on pavement (look at tanks, etc)

Re:Where will artificial general intelligence come from? by paganel on Saturday September 02, 2017 @07:25PM (#15158797)
It's not about building better tools (i.e. the "artificial" wheels vs. nature's wings and legs), it's about building a thing that would be just like us, humans: intelligent and especially a thing that has feelings.

I know that the "feelings" part is most of the times neglected in these types of presentations (you cannot put them into any abstract representation, like you can draw a wheel using geometry), but it's what most of us, people who are not in this field, expect from AIG. Great Science Fiction works (novels, movies) have talked about this subject (AI and human feelings) long enough, but it somehow never makes it into academic presentations.

Just think for a second of the self-driving cars problem. Someone on HN (or maybe reddit) explained a couple of days ago that even if we 'd manage to devise such a system that would be considerably better compared to humans we'd still not be ok with these machines killing us on the roads. Now, imagine these machines possessing the feeling of "guilt", or of "compassion", I'm pretty sure that the percentage of humans that would become ok with some AIG driving our cars for us will rise dramatically (I know I would stand on the AIG's side). We don't mind the fact that machines kill us, accidents happen, we mind that machines kill us and they don't "realize" what they've done and they don't support the consequences.

Re-reading my comment I feel like it sounds a little pop-sciency, didn't mean it to go into that direction, it's just my interpretation on how I think things are. I for myself would love, really love, if we'd somehow "make" an AIG capable of telling genuine, funny jokes.

Re:Where will artificial general intelligence come from? by serf on Saturday September 02, 2017 @06:48PM (#15158641)
>I know of no biological forms that have evolved wheels.

Silly to reduce all rotary motion to wheels.

Less complex to roll as a ball -- the benefit of rotary motion without facilitating the additional complexity of adding a steering mechanism.

> But wheels have turned out to be a hell of a lot faster than fins or legs.

Nature doesn't somehow cares about hyper-optimizing for a single characteristic like 'speed', rather the characteristics arise from individual (species) successes between genetics lines.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotating_locomotion_in_living_...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Rolling_animals

Re:Where will artificial general intelligence come from? by skummetmaelk on Saturday September 02, 2017 @02:08PM (#15157379)
Wheels are useless if you don't have roads.

EDIT: Please explain your downvotes here? Don't you people see that this, coupled with there being no useful intermediate stage before developing a full wheel, prevents evolution from "inventing" it.

Re:Where will artificial general intelligence come from? by jamiek88 on Saturday September 02, 2017 @02:23PM (#15157426)
Well that's not true at all.

See: Wheelbarrow; amongst many wheeled devices I can think of immediately.

Re:Where will artificial general intelligence come from? by PeterisP on Saturday September 02, 2017 @05:16PM (#15158254)
Wheelbarrows are a prime counterexample - historically, in environments that had decent man-made trails, wheelbarrows were useful and used; in environments that did not, pack-carrying animals or even people did the job even though the concept of wheelbarrows was known; also, the availability of roads (as opposed to narrow trails) was the prime reason for differences of usage of wheelbarrows (especially the efficient middle-wheel variety e.g. https://www.google.lv/search?q=wheelbarrow+chinese&tbm=isch ) versus two or four wheel animal (or man) pulled carts, which were popular only where roads had been made and were maintainable, so not in jungle-like environments where it takes more work to keep a road from overgrowing.
Re:Where will artificial general intelligence come from? by skummetmaelk on Saturday September 02, 2017 @02:31PM (#15157467)
Wheelbarrow creatures? I don't see how that would be advantageous at all.

Also, try running around with a wheelbarrow in a dense forest.

Re:Where will artificial general intelligence come from? by return0 on Saturday September 02, 2017 @05:52PM (#15158416)
Apparently philosophers have pondered on the matter, it's called the multiple realizability problem.
Re:Where will artificial general intelligence come from? by V-2 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @07:39AM (#15160934)
You can't really evolve a wheel in the sense that a half-evolved foot is useful already, whereas a half-evolved wheel: not really. Therefore obtaining a functional wheel has to be done in one jump, which is contrary to how the gradual process of evolution works.
Re:Where will artificial general intelligence come from? by posterboy on Monday September 04, 2017 @01:46AM (#15165978)
Wheels are way more basic. Anything will skid and slide on a spread of rubble, doesn't even need to be animated.
Re:Where will artificial general intelligence come from? by npgatech on Saturday September 02, 2017 @01:50PM (#15157301)
Fair point, but you are omitting the fact that brain itself (that invented the wheel) was evolved through biological means.

That said, evolutionary optimization is generally considered unreliable(convergence) and inefficient.

Re:Where will artificial general intelligence come from? by mythrwy on Saturday September 02, 2017 @01:58PM (#15157340)
The wheel existed before the mind did. It was just sitting there waiting to be noticed :)
Re:Where will artificial general intelligence come from? by pookeh on Saturday September 02, 2017 @02:03PM (#15157364)
Not for the function the brain made a use of it.
Re:Where will artificial general intelligence come from? by korzun on Saturday September 02, 2017 @05:33PM (#15158324)
The wheel, by itself, is not faster than legs. It does not adapt, repair, or feel. You will always need more than your legs to create a system that properly utilizes wheels.

There is nothing intelligent about artificial intelligence. You might as well call it artificial stupidity, but that doesn't make you sound sophisticated.

Memorizing the results of a pre-defined concept faster due to a lower barrier of entry does not make you smarter or more intelligent. You can process all of the traffic signals in the world in a blink of an eye only to get stomped by a dancing traffic director.

You can't have AI without a human, and you can't have AI with a human.