News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Death and Life of Helicopter Commuting [video] by Gravityloss on Friday September 01, 2017 @06:55AM (#15147418)
If you have fixed pitch, you can't really autorotate anyway. Safety would be provided by redundancy.

With collective pitch, it becomes interesting. Does the motor help or hinder autorotation?

In a hybrid system, you anyway decouple the propeller and turbine with the electric system.

Your car gearbox operates at much lower speeds (because it's not attached to a turbine) and has a lot less weight constraints. Helicopter powertrains require a lot of maintenance.

The stack exchange link talks about jetliners while we're talking about copters.

Re:The Death and Life of Helicopter Commuting [video] by Alupis on Friday September 01, 2017 @01:08PM (#15150357)
> If you have fixed pitch, you can't really autorotate anyway

Helicopters are not fixed pitch... your run-of-the-mill hobby multi-rotor is, but that's due to the reasons mentioned above in my previous posts (eg. simplicity at this small scale).

> Safety would be provided by redundancy

Unless you suffer a total electric failure. Or even just a failure on one side of the aircraft (or even just one motor, in a quad setup). Being able to mechanically work these systems is fairly important, since it's less likely both mechanical and electrical systems fail simultaneously.

> In a hybrid system, you anyway decouple the propeller and turbine with the electric system

Unless your electric system is the failure.

> Your car gearbox operates at much lower speeds (because it's not attached to a turbine)

Even some model multi-rotors use gearboxes. You have a motor, spinning either slower or faster than the desired RPM for the rotors... a gearbox solves that difference, and provides a mechanical means of fully decoupling from the motor should the need arise.

> Helicopter powertrains require a lot of maintenance

This is true, but this is not really an issue... and nobody really is looking to "solve" this non-problem. Aircraft require a lot of maintenance and inspections.