News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:"Artificial Intelligence" Gains Fans Among Investors by motters on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @10:05AM (#1514574)
Having tried to do this sort of thing in the past, I'm fairly skeptical. Maybe if you're trading in large volumes over short spaces of time you can make money with AI, but at least in my simulated runs with small scale investment the results didn't look encouraging.

Also it should be borne in mind that this kind of activity isn't really making any constructive or lasting contribution to society. It's really just moving money around slightly more efficiently than previously. If you really want to change the world, do something else.

Re:"Artificial Intelligence" Gains Fans Among Investors by vecter on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @10:25AM (#1514620)
Also it should be borne in mind that this kind of activity isn't really making any constructive or lasting contribution to society. It's really just moving money around slightly more efficiently than previously.

I disagree. Efficient allocation of capital is what allowed modern society to advance as far as it did. Capital markets are a tremendous innovation and add tons of value to society. Almost every startup turned major corporation out there was capitalized by the financial markets. You trivialize this value when you say investing is simply "moving money around more efficiently". That money NEEDS to be moved around more efficiently so the most productive members and organizations in society are (a) given the resources to expand their business and (b) rewarded for the value they add to society.

Re:"Artificial Intelligence" Gains Fans Among Investors by jey on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @12:18PM (#1515044)
He isn't disputing the fact that it has net-positive value creation. He's just saying that it's a tiny lever in terms of impact. You'll immeasurably increase market efficiency, but you'll still get a lot of money because finance is an area with a very high money-to-value ratio.
Re:"Artificial Intelligence" Gains Fans Among Investors by JabavuAdams on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @03:20PM (#1515647)
Yes, increased liquidity has allowed us to more efficiently raise capital, but beware the liquidity dogma.

Increased liquidity has been good in the past, so anything that increases liquidity must be good.

Not necessarily. What are the other effects? How much do we value those? Can we even estimate them a priori?

OTOH, I would argue that most web apps proposed on this site aren't really making any lasting or constructive contribution to society.

The one thing that can be said is that web-startup founders as a whole are less powerful and perhaps less cynically self-serving than financiers, so they distort government policy less.

Re:"Artificial Intelligence" Gains Fans Among Investors by cameldrv on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @11:30AM (#1514860)
Perhaps, but most of those funding decisions were not made in the public markets. Those capital allocations were made by angels, VCs, and the people who committed to investing in the IPO of the company. The only thing that the overall stock market directly controls for capital allocation is secondary offerings, which are a very small part of the allocation of productive capital. The stock market just serves to trade pieces of capital that already exist. Having the stock market be a bit more accurate, particularly on short timescales, doesn't really affect capital allocation.
Re:"Artificial Intelligence" Gains Fans Among Investors by lkozma on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @10:40AM (#1514671)
"isn't really making any constructive or lasting contribution to society"

The common argument is that if you are increasing overall efficiency, that means that capital can be more readily available for real businesses which do make lasting contributions (often in the form of polluting the environment, but that's another question).

It seems your argument is a bit simplistic. Couldn't the same logic be applied to the distribution of goods, middlemen, marketplaces, banking, etc. Are you dismissing all those?

Re:"Artificial Intelligence" Gains Fans Among Investors by dagheti on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @11:11AM (#1514791)
This is true only if we accept that AI trading is actually making the market more efficient. The 'wisdom' of crowds is often foolishness, and this could be even more true for a crowd of computers.

It is very possible that by using AI that looks mostly at numbers for trading is just destabilizing by relying too heavily on specific variables (the ones the algorithms can actually use as inputs) , and reduces efficient allocation of capital.

Re:"Artificial Intelligence" Gains Fans Among Investors by motters on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @12:09PM (#1515011)
I tend to agree. One of the difficult problems with using AI for market predictions is that the market includes human psychology in the loop, which is not always rational and there are factors which are difficult to include within the model. When people are making buying or selling decisions they're often factoring in imponderables such as gossip, personal prejudices and vague hunches. These hard to simulate decision processes are then greatly amplified by positive feedback - which includes automated trading systems.
Re:"Artificial Intelligence" Gains Fans Among Investors by vecter on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @11:19AM (#1514817)
This is false. You can't make money by being consistently wrong about the "true" value of an asset. Then, the only way you can stay in business is to sell the asset when it's too high, and buy it when it's too low. Notice how doing this actually decreases the amplitude of the oscillations. If you're selling at a high point, you're pushing the price back down. Likewise, if you're buying at a low point, you're pushing the price back up (both times, towards its "true" value).

The reason I use "true" in quotes is because no one really knows the value of an asset. The only real estimate we have is the market estimate. Let me put it another way: if you don't believe markets efficiently allocate capital, then how would you propose we do it? By fiat?

Once again, I want to emphasize that you cannot be wrong about the value of an asset and consistently make money. If these AI algorithms are consistently making money, then they are, more often than not, accurately predicting the value of that asset (where value is defined as the future market price). Of course, my argument hinges on the market price being "right", but like I said, markets are the best way we know how to value things.

Re:"Artificial Intelligence" Gains Fans Among Investors by JabavuAdams on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @03:27PM (#1515661)
What is the true value of an asset?

There are many theories on this, and "what someone else will pay for it" is just one. Investors are not rational!

Re:"Artificial Intelligence" Gains Fans Among Investors by vecter on Thursday July 15, 2010 @10:03AM (#1517808)
I'm not even talking about investors. I'm talking about how to price an apple. Do you think there's a better way to price it than by the free market?

Note that I'm not advocating getting rid of regulation -- I think that's very important, since most businesses don't correctly price in externalities, a la BP and the 2008 crash. To answer your question, though, he point I'm making is that no one knows the true value of an asset. That's why we have markets: to help us price them. Unless we have a better mechanism for pricing assets (anything, not just stocks), we should take the market price as close to fair.

Re:"Artificial Intelligence" Gains Fans Among Investors by cameldrv on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @11:25AM (#1514842)
Yes, but does it really matter if stocks are priced marginally more accurately? How does that significantly increase the productive output of the economy?
Re:"Artificial Intelligence" Gains Fans Among Investors by vecter on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @11:37AM (#1514891)
Suppose a pension fund wants to buy 10 million shares of MSFT. Suppose the "real" price of MSFT is $22.00 and the market price is $22.05. That amounts to roughly $500,000 in extra costs for its clients (may be more or less, because the transaction will have price impact and probably rip through a few levels of the bid/ask book). These costs are forwarded to you and me, the customers of the pension fund. Multiply this by the trillions of shares being traded every year, and that adds up to a huge difference.
Re:"Artificial Intelligence" Gains Fans Among Investors by cameldrv on Thursday July 15, 2010 @01:58AM (#1517071)
Yes, but in that case, they're probably buying from another pension fund, or a mutual fund, or someone. If they pay 500k less, that's 500k less the other pension fund doesn't get. No value is created or destroyed by people trading at marginally wrong prices. Furthermore, as long as it's the same people trading with each other at randomly wrong prices, things even out in the wash. These days though, you're dealing with PhDs doing nothing but programming computers to trade, and extracting the money from these mistakes. This makes it not even out in the wash anymore, and they're being paid billions of dollars to solve a problem that never existed. I would much rather have those PhDs figure out how to program a computer to make an electric car that is 5% more efficient, or a wind turbine that is 5% more efficient, or a search engine that is 5% more accurate, or even figure out how to make a physical constant known to 5% greater accuracy. All of those things increase the total value in the world. Instead, they're all being siphoned off by trading companies to do things that make them money, but don't create much if any value.
Re:"Artificial Intelligence" Gains Fans Among Investors by orp on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @10:48AM (#1514704)
'Also it should be borne in mind that this kind of activity isn't really making any constructive or lasting contribution to society. It's really just moving money around slightly more efficiently than previously. If you really want to change the world, do something else.'

I agree completely. While have reasonably efficient capital markets is necessary for society, its very hard to show that the marginal improvement offered by this kind of activity justifies the massive amounts of effort that go into it, just because: 1. It's cool. 2. It can make a lot of money.

But unlike making money out of making something people want (e.g. providing value), here you're making money (if you succeed) out of very small market inefficiencies that are probably not hurting anyone, or even just by being 1ms faster then the other guys who were already catching them anyway,

Re:"Artificial Intelligence" Gains Fans Among Investors by wisty on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @10:48AM (#1514707)
Putting Wall Street traders out of work seems like an efficient use of capital ;)
Re:"Artificial Intelligence" Gains Fans Among Investors by yummyfajitas on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @11:04AM (#1514769)
Putting anyone out of work is an efficient use of capital.
Re:"Artificial Intelligence" Gains Fans Among Investors by dmix on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @10:15AM (#1514601)
> this kind of activity isn't really making any constructive or lasting contribution to society

There was an interesting discussion about this on quora: http://www.quora.com/Is-high-frequency-trading-good-for-the-...