Re:The Accidental Elitist: Academia is too important to be l...
by mcguire on Thursday August 31, 2017 @10:16AM
(#15140456)
"Then, halfway through the panel, it hits me: this is awful. The redeeming insights are just so few and far between, stranded between deserts of lame, forced conference humor and straightforward, even banal points dressed up in comically unnecessary jargon."
Welcome to the land of adulthood, where everything is like this.
There's an old joke about the American hiker in Japan going to the inn in a small village in the evening and asking for a room. The innkeeper says in Japanese, "you wouldn't like it here, we have Japanese bathrooms." The hiker replies in Japanese that he has been in Japan for months and would be fine. They go back and forth a couple of times until the hiker in frustration says, in English, "Why can't I just get a place to sleep?" The innkeeper replies, "Because you don't speak Japanese," and slams the door.
Anyway, this kind of behavior is everywhere, especially in any field that does not look difficult. Yes, I have a PhD in computer science. No, I don't fix PCs all day.
The bottom line is that the author is part of the problem. The article is excessively erudite and verbose. He's clearly not talking to anyone outside of his field. He misrepresents the state of the "other side" to make points. (Quick, call up the ghost of William F. Buckley and ask him about the state of the American right.) And he is not saying anything new.
Welcome to the land of adulthood, where everything is like this.
There's an old joke about the American hiker in Japan going to the inn in a small village in the evening and asking for a room. The innkeeper says in Japanese, "you wouldn't like it here, we have Japanese bathrooms." The hiker replies in Japanese that he has been in Japan for months and would be fine. They go back and forth a couple of times until the hiker in frustration says, in English, "Why can't I just get a place to sleep?" The innkeeper replies, "Because you don't speak Japanese," and slams the door.
Anyway, this kind of behavior is everywhere, especially in any field that does not look difficult. Yes, I have a PhD in computer science. No, I don't fix PCs all day.
The bottom line is that the author is part of the problem. The article is excessively erudite and verbose. He's clearly not talking to anyone outside of his field. He misrepresents the state of the "other side" to make points. (Quick, call up the ghost of William F. Buckley and ask him about the state of the American right.) And he is not saying anything new.