News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:If you believe in science you're doing it wrong by drewcrawford on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @03:09AM (#1513902)
>So it's not a fault of science that it does not answer that question.

Similarly, it's not the question's fault that science cannot answer it.

I say "subjectively" because it is not an objective fact that the question has value or is meaningful. Clearly, you and many others view it as "empty". I don't. In that sense the value or utility of the question is subjective.

Re:If you believe in science you're doing it wrong by Helianthus16 on Wednesday July 14, 2010 @03:24AM (#1513928)
I don't particularly view it as empty, I just think it lies outside the framework of practicality.

It's like asking about the nature of hobbits. (Actually, this does have practical provenance in certain circles, but let's try to overlook that for a bit.) Hobbit qualities can be essentially whatever we want them to be, so their precise nature only matters insofar as they reflect our desires. We desire to hold true to Tolkien's vision, so we accept his details as truth and might extrapolate a bit here and there.

That doesn't mean the question has any bearing on reality.

Similarly, I could ask, why isn't there a force that could destroy our reality retroactively, eating through space and time a la the Nothing of the Never-Ending Story?

And the answer is more or less, if it happened, we would know (or rather, not know anymore) by now. The question assumes that there could be such a thing.

I suppose I view "Why doesn't the universe not exist?" in the same light.