Re:Restic Cryptography
by iofiiiiiiiii on Thursday August 31, 2017 @07:34AM
(#15139571)
Can you go into more detail? What are the common gotchas when implementing ETM yourself?
The classic example is not MAC'ing the IV.
Re:Restic Cryptography
by loup-vaillant on Thursday August 31, 2017 @07:03PM
(#15144729)
Wait a minute, there are cases where this is required? Chacha20/Poly1305 is not one of them, right?
---
Another I have personally seen was using the session key for a Wegman Carter hash (such as Poly1305). I received an email suggesting I do just that in Monocypher, to avoid using up the beginning of the key stream. Didn't realise why this would lead to instant key recovery.
I have since littered my manual with scary tales of total annihilation of security.
In particular: you can easily end up with AE w/o AD by doing DIY ETM, and end up with serious exploitable bugs.