Re:How Not to Sort by Average Rating (2009)
by yoz-y on Thursday August 31, 2017 @03:38AM
(#15138766)
For a single data point they are useless. But I thing a rating in aggregate could be informative. Of course, the rating is self defeating as too many people who were positively surprised will raise the expectations.
For movies I would love to have reviews in style: Somebody writes up their expectations before going to the movie, and then rates the movie according to that. I find most "press and critics" reviews useless as if somebody is not a fan of story-less action movies, then why the hell is he reviewing them.
To use an example I gave elsewhere. I order a cable from Amazon. It works. Therefore it met my expectations of a working cable. Yet, I think most people would interpret a 3-star rating as my being lukewarm on my purchase. I'm not. But what the heck do I expect a cable to do other than being a fair price and to work?
With respect to movies. Some movies get really built up and I go in expecting great things (e.g. Fury Road). I come out thinking they were just OK. So maybe 3 stars. But definitely not -1 or 2 stars. My personal expectations aren't necessarily a good baseline.