Re:The Church of Agile
by lasereyes136 on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @06:31PM
(#15136668)
I agree with your statements.
But it has nothing to do with Agile or Scrum. It all has to do with company culture. It reminds me of my favorite Henrik Kniberg quote "If your company doesn't like the truth, than maybe Agile isn't for you". Very few companies realize value from script kiddies on a constant death march (great quote BTW) and that prevents no one from trying.
Unfortunately, "Agile" is now mainstream bullshit, and, as you say, its now used by the business to just bypass any kind of engineering mastery, and just hire a bunch of junior devs and tell them what to do. "Scrum masters" are just "yes men". Most times, when a company says "We do Agile" they mean "We hired a bunch of script kiddies on a constant death march".
Scrum is about empowering developers, but Scrum itself does not empower them. If the developers are already empowered, then I believe it's useful for communication and direction. If the developers are not already empowered, then Scrum is actively bad. Scrum cannot empower developers. Scrum with disempowered developers is just disempowered developers but now without any kind of SDLC safety net.