News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by 3pt14159 on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @11:45AM (#15133097)
We should be cautious, but provided the scientific community is ok with it, I see no reason to limit editing human DNA to just treating disease.

What is the downside of increasing the number of geniuses? What is the downside of saving someone from dealing with severe teenage acne? Why should some men have to worry about their genitalia being well below average in size? Why should some women never experience an orgasm?

I get the instinctual revulsion to the idea of playing God or reducing our diversity, but I try to model my ethics as if I didn't know who I was going to be in the simulation before hand. These are changes that we should be advocating for if they are possible.

Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by waiquoo on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @11:58AM (#15133226)
The issue as I see it is that this is effectively an advanced form of eugenics. The idea behind eugenics (improving the lives of future people) is probably not bad, as you say, what is the downside in increasing the number of geniuses and reducing the incidence of defects? Who doesn't want their children to be strong, beautiful, smart, and happy? The problem is that people are dicks and we will probably end up in an arms race to some sort of superhuman masterrace. It will be like going to college, where before not everyone needed to go to college, but now you have to get a 4 year degree to compete for entry level jobs (I realize there are exceptions, but you know what I mean). We need to be cautious not to end up in a GATTACA situation.
Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by mooseburger on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @12:27PM (#15133491)
The only real problem with the GATTACA world was that not everyone got the genetic enhancements, creating an underclass. If everyone got the mods, what's the downside?

Well, I guess Jude Law's character couldn't live with the idea of being completely engineered for winning, and still losing. But his problem seems orthogonal to widespread genetic engineering. Everyone has their ambitions thwarted at some point. It has always been a problem humans faced. Hell, maybe even that can be engineered away, by being created with low propensity for self-loathing.

Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by j9461701 on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @02:49PM (#15134835)
Everyone was offered the enhancements, but the protagonist's parents refused them because they were reactionary luddites. Then when their son was born, not only was he un-enhanced, but he had a severe heart defect that would probably kill him by 30. The parents are the bad guys in this scenario, not the society that offered them the tools to fix their kid and were refused.

It's like when modern parents refuse to vaccinate their children - if that kid gets Polio and is crippled for life, that doesn't mean we should abandon vaccinations because we're creating "an unvaccinated underclass". It just means that kid's parents were stupid and ruined their son's life.

>Well, I guess Jude Law's character couldn't live with the idea of being completely engineered for winning, and still losing.

Jude Law's character illustrates one of the flaws the movie has: It was made in the '90s, when our understanding of the power and scope of the influence of genetics was quite primitive. A genetically enhanced person would probably not only be a beautiful genius, but also highly resistant to depression, anxiety, mental illness and even low self-esteem.

Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by maxerickson on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @02:59PM (#15134926)
Is it made clear how much the screening costs (there was no enhancement in the movie, just screening)?

The scene where they read out Vincent's future life sure makes it sound like the story considers mental health:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eRpQMW77T_o

Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by waiquoo on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @01:38PM (#15134200)
So we should eliminate all the undesirables? Or manipulate the undesirables until they are desirable? Who chooses what traits are desirable, even if they are universally applied. I'm not arguing that this isn't amazing technology that could potentially cure a lot of disabling diseases, that possibility is very exciting. I am just stating that there are some tricky ethical dilemmas involved.
Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by FullMtlAlcoholc on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @05:47PM (#15136340)
We're already doing this. In Iceland, 85% of prospective parents who receive prenatal testing and discover that their children will have Down's Syndrome choose to terminate the pregnancy. Tay Sachs disease, a condition that afflicts ashekenazi jews, has been eradicated due to abortion upon diagnosis and carrier screening tests for couples that determines their "genetic suitability"

I don't understand peole who are fearful of the elimination of genetic diseases that cause. The majority of articles I read on this subject are littered with lines such as these:

"Deciding what sorts of lives are worth living brings us disturbingly close to the bygone era of eugenics, when only the “right” sorts of people were supposed to procreate."

It's not crazy to think that parents do not want to have to spend extra resources on education and basically support their child not only until their death, but having to arrange for their offspring's care after they perish.

I would like to see these people who think along these lines adopt Down's Syndrome children if they think it is so important. Perhaps if prospective parents know that there is someone willing to take care of their disabled children, more of them may go through with the pregnancy.

Also, if diseases like these end up offering some sort of survival advantage in a future scenario, we still have the genetic data to recreate the condition. it's not like Down's Syndrome or other genetic diseases are going to completely disappear. Also, there will doubtlessly be groups of people who for religious reasons or otherwise will elect not to get treatment

Does anyone regret the virtual elimination of polio or smallpox?

Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by concede_pluto on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @05:52PM (#15136384)
There's a huge difference between not conceiving people and eliminating the ones already here.
Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by thinkcontext on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @01:43PM (#15134253)
Since germline manipulation requires IVF its likely to remain inaccessible for all but the rich for quite some time.
Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by emmab on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @12:55PM (#15133770)
> If everyone got the mods, what's the downside?

You can't get germline gene therapy if you're not a zygote.

Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by sqeaky on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @01:08PM (#15133889)
Yet?

There is not property of physics that stop us from making the tech. It won't e in the first gen tech, but with all those 20 something geniuses coming out of college they can start working on that tech before too many generations pass.

Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by chrchang523 on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @01:00PM (#15133817)
The Amish have peacefully opted out of this sort of arms race for hundreds of years, and are in no danger.
Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by waiquoo on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @01:07PM (#15133878)
(I realize there are exceptions, but you know what I mean)
Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by Retric on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @11:46AM (#15133106)
IMO, the core issue is we simply don't understand DNA that well and are likely to introduce many problems potentially across a huge swath of the population.

Disease treatments on the other hand are likely a lot more straightforward and the net gains are also likely larger.

Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by sqeaky on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @01:11PM (#15133921)
There are risks with all activities. The kind of gaps in our knowledge are smaller than ever and there if the experts say there is no obvious risk we would remiss to disregard them.

There will always be the risk of the unknown, there is still the risk of the unknown with seemingly every day things like cars. The utility of cars and gene therapies is so large that we really can't afford for all the data to come in.

Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by Retric on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @03:54PM (#15135398)
It's a question of sum(risk * each downside) vs benefit. Large scale genetic editing for cosmetic reasons has minimal benefit and several high risks with large associated downsides.

Protein folding as a tiny example is something we have trouble simulating, expanding to multi cellular mechanisms across a lifetime is basically impossible without directly testing it. And those tests will be done on people. Prions are just an example of the kind of issues people will be dealing with. It’s really not just about inserting some code from somewhere else it’s a question of how physical structures interact and degrade.

Long term I have no problem with it. But, right now we could give children blue hair for example but we have no idea what else that might cause.

PS: That said, copying things from other humans is probably significantly safer and this editing will take place. I just don't think we should introduce it at the society level without at least a lifetime of test data and significant sample sizes.

Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by dontreact on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @12:44PM (#15133660)
The downside would be that if we modify or select only for intelligence, we may get morally worse individuals. Perhaps morality and intelligence are somewhat correlated, but that may break down if we explicitly select only for intelligence. Imagine flooding the world with ultra-smart ultra-selfish hackers who manage to break all security systems and steal all the wealth or otherwise wreak self serving havoc.
Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by j9461701 on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @01:50PM (#15134307)
Crime is a really stupid way to make money. I mean objectively, the cost benefit analysis just doesn't make any sense. The only reason to do it is you have poor impulse control and can't succeed in normal financial activities.

An ultra-smart ultra-selfish hacker would sit down, do the math, and spend 5 years killing it on Wall-street doing quasi-legal machine trading in total safety. Rather than risk imprisonment and permanently damaging his career prospects over a few thousand dollars from Grandma's credit card.

Case in point:

Carl Gugasian, graduated with a degree in electrical engineering. Got a masters in systems analysis, and was a PhD student in statistics. His intelligent, methodical approach to robbing banks let him get away with it for 30 years. He earned about 2 million dollars doing it, which is about a million less than his undergraduate engineering degree alone would have earned him during that same period if he'd just gotten a regular job.

He also eventually got caught, through pure dumb chance he couldn't have planned for, and spent 20 years in prison. So not only did he make less money being a criminal, he got to go to federal pound me in the ass prison for his golden years.

Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by sbierwagen on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @12:57PM (#15133784)
Your comment is phrased as if antisocial traits don't already confer greater reproductive success.

http://www.ehbonline.org/article/S1090-5138%2814%2900077-4/a...

>Convicted criminal offenders had more children than individuals never convicted of a criminal offense. Criminal offenders also had more reproductive partners, were less often married, more likely to get remarried if ever married, and had more often contracted a sexually transmitted disease than non-offenders. Importantly, the increased reproductive success of criminals was explained by a fertility increase from having children with several different partners.

Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by dontreact on Sunday September 03, 2017 @08:47PM (#15164848)
I wonder if there is a lower chance of success for children with absent fathers which offsets this. I would be surprised if there wasn't, given the long term trend of societies becoming more civil and less violent on average.
Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by pebers on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @01:06PM (#15133861)
Why would we expect to get morally worse individuals? Given that we would not be making any changes in that area (if there even is any area of the genome that corresponds to morality) you'd expect it to be unchanged overall - unless it negatively correlates with intelligence, but I don't know of anything proving that's the case.
Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by dontreact on Sunday September 03, 2017 @08:42PM (#15164834)
Would be pretty surprising if there was no hereditary component to morality. If there currently is any selective pressure towards pro-social traits or morality, then selecting exclusively for intelligence would take this away and you would see a decline.
Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by BearGoesChirp on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @12:50PM (#15133710)
Compared to the current qualities we select for? Breeding among humans is by no means random, and I think selecting for intelligence would be an improvement.

I think the bigger concern is how we select for intelligence. Doing it based on a few genes that correlate strongly with intelligence can lead to an increased vulnerability to health issues related to those genes we don't know about, but I think this applies to any gene level selection based on any characteristics.

Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by dontreact on Sunday September 03, 2017 @08:49PM (#15164856)
Right I guess that part of my point is that even if you resolve all those issues you would still really want to select for is intelligence and pro-social/moral behavior in order to optimize the positive impact of a person.
Re:Two-thirds of Americans approve of editing human DNA to t... by vbuwivbiu on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @12:41PM (#15133631)
There's no downside. It's only the same as what we did with smallpox and polio. I'm all for it: I'd get genedrives for all kinds of genetically-determined diseases.

What concerns me is how genes affect personality. I don't want a world of geniuses if a side-effect is they're all nasty people. Now I like to think that smarter people are also nicer, on the whole. And violence is often associated with frontal-lobe defects. I would like to live in a happier more secure world, and if that means engineering people to be nicer, less murderous people then so be it. But that's Clockwork Orange territory.