IMHO, most of the NoSQL hype was developers not wanting to learn sql/ddl along with a lot of resume padding. It is also important to note that NoSQL no longer means "No SQL" but really is now "Not Relational and/or ACID" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ACID). The only thing worse than SQL is everything else created to replace it. Many "NoSQL" products use a limited SQL like syntax as their only query format.
As for relational DB overhead, there is no reason for it be more then NoSQL(see sqlite) unless you are willing to give up part of ACID. Special cases like this are another use case for NoSQL but you probably want ACID unless you have data/throughput to make it nonviable. Otherwise you have it just ignore issues (normally what happens) or code for them in your app.
If you are in case 3, then is that when NoSQL allegedly starts paying off? If so, is the payoff in actual performance or just not having to write SQL?
I know you said that you could just use the NoSQL features of the relational DB. If you really truely know for certain that you will never need to join your data, then isn't using an entire relational DB software package a lot more overhead?