News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by simonbarker87 on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @11:11AM (#15132771)
The biggest thing I noticed when starting my PhD was all the first and second years derping around not doing much, all the third years panicking and "just getting going" and all the 4th and 5th years really grinding.

So, I inverted that and worked my ass off like I was still an undergrad in the first 18 months, toned it down for the next year and submitted my thesis at 2 years 10 months (the earliest my university would allow a submission) and was viva'd and passed 2 months later with minor corrections.

PhDs taking forever is generally a lack of initial work by the student rather than any external factors. Too many students let their supervisors fob them off rather than getting in their office when needed and forcing their projects forward.

Also, selecting a sensible area with a high likelihood of novelty helps, I worked on energy harvesting for hostile environments (high temp photovoltaics, piezo etc at 300degC) which was a new area for the group and my supervisor, and published 6 papers as basically nobody else was working in the field.

Doing a PhD in the UK helps, in and out before the funding dries up in 3-4 years is expected along with no class requirements and no masters needed (can go in straight from Bachelors).

Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by xaa on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @12:17PM (#15133406)
Wow. I just defended a few weeks ago, at 7 years. And honestly, until about year 5, I felt no rush whatsoever to get out. Not that I was derping around -- I finished with 20+ papers -- but I was enjoying it, and I realized that once I was out, two undesirable things would happen:

- I would have to start running the grant treadmill (and indeed, I'm just in the middle of finalizing a training grant that has as one of its requirements...that I must write another grant)

- In the US NIH, there is a 10 year "New Investigator" status that lasts 10 years from the PhD, where you are preferred for certain types of grant awards. So I reasoned it is much better to graduate late and start this clock from a strong position than to rush up the hierarchy and find yourself victim of the Peter Principle.

So for me, delay was a conscious strategy. Only downside was I had to live on a modest stipend. It was worth it for me, though. Another point that I'm making is that "productivity" is not equivalent to "graduating/getting promoted as fast as possible".

As for TFA, I would say that amazing quantities of work can get done by pushing yourself, deadlines, etc, but the creative work that lays groundwork for future growth only occurs during low-stress periods. I try, therefore, to set up alternating periods of both types.

Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by simonbarker87 on Thursday August 31, 2017 @05:06AM (#15139096)
Congratulations! I should have clarified in my initial post that:

1. I had no intention to stay in academia after my PhD, it was the best paying gig I could find in 2008 when the world was ending financially and the project was interesting with very little supervisory oversight as the area was new to him as well. 2. If you are enjoying the work, the funding is there and you feel like you are achieving what you want then taking your time is totally cool - I was more focussing on their other end when people want to finish up and can't get done.

Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by agumonkey on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @03:11PM (#15135014)
Did you have trouble extending to 7 years ?
Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by xaa on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @03:34PM (#15135220)
Not really. My salary was funded by my PI and he was happy to keep someone at my skill level as long as I wanted (and at a bargain salary to boot).

From my department and committee, I started to feel rumblings around mid-year-6 of the "you should get on with it" lines. But they weren't trying to force me out or anything, it was more like concern.

I was spending (and still do) a much bigger percentage of my time on collaborative work than my peers, and they were concerned I wasn't adequately focused on my own career. But that wasn't the case at all -- I was doing what I thought was in my best interests, especially considering my field (bioinformatics) is inherently highly collaborative compared to the wet-lab stuff going on around me.

However, there were some institution-level reasons I cut it off at 7. After that, the institution's policy is that you have to start re-taking some classes you already took (and passed). It was irritating to always have to go to an irrelevant journal club every week (I was in a department that really had nothing to do with my research). Also, I had some appealing opportunities available if I finished when I did. But in no way was I "forced out".

Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by agumonkey on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @03:59PM (#15135445)
Interesting, very interesting. Thanks for the reply. Would you like to share a link to your thesis ?
Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by xaa on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @04:10PM (#15135555)
Oh, God, I'm not sure anyone is totally happy with their dissertation, but I guess I should get over it. I got about 2/3 of what I wanted to done. I'm continuing with the project, though.

https://www.dropbox.com/sh/ujf73cdu4m6p1lj/AAD4vVwpCfgSf7GGo...

Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by agumonkey on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @04:34PM (#15135768)
Don't worry, I cannot judge anything anyway. I just read you were into aging research. I went at a few senescence panels a few months ago and am very curious about the subject. Is your thesis a step into finding applications for this domain ? or more general ?

ps: sexy title

Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by xaa on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @04:45PM (#15135845)
Well the project arose like this. I got interested in aging halfway through the PhD. I started collaborating heavily with aging people at my institution. But there are so many papers and so much data to get informed about the area.

So I wondered "is there some semi-empirical way to find out what is 'most important' in aging so I can focus my future efforts on that?"

The solution I hit on was to take all the available gene expression data and to build a system to ask "what genes/pathways/systems change most strongly and consistently with age across species, experimental conditions, and tissues"? This would be a "core aging signature", if it exists. Obviously this is only one of many ways to answer my question and neglects epigenetics, proteomics, etc, although we're currently extending the system to DNA methylation. There is not enough high-throughput proteomics data to make it possible to do this with protein yet. We do not use sequencing for now because it is much more of a processing burden and human RNA is behind dbGaP embargo. And at the time I started this, there really wasn't that much of it compared to GEO.

My boss's interests are much more general than aging, so he encouraged me to develop the system to be more generic while still answering my question, which I did. It became a general meta-analysis system for asking "what genes change expression with <arbitrary condition> across the available experiments in GEO?" We found other things we could do with such a huge amount of expression data, and some of them are in Chapter 5.

I would say the system itself is 80-90% done. But sadly I did not get to a really detailed analysis of aging yet, although my findings so far on that are in Chapter 4.

Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by agumonkey on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @04:57PM (#15135943)
Aight, wonderful idea. I wish De Grey and his friends get to see this system.
Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by xaa on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @05:46PM (#15136324)
Thanks for your interest. I've actually met him once -- a friend of his I was talking to over beers introduced us -- but at the time, he was seemingly more interested in his pending date with the blonde he had just picked up than talking with a lowly graduate student. Can't say I blame him :) His papers are excellent, though. A more philosophical and broad approach is needed in aging, I think. He has mellowed a lot from the exaggerated claims he was making in the early 2000s. Maybe he saw my poster which covered an early version of this work, but we didn't talk about that.

The best aging researcher alive right now IMO though is Jim Kirkland. I've had the good fortune to work a little with him and the man is a living encyclopedia. His brilliance is obvious even in a conference full of PhDs.

Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by agumonkey on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @05:59PM (#15136445)
haha so not surprised by your anecdote, I met him only once but it seems very degrey. Doesn't waste time.

From I what I could hear, he has to spend a lot of time managing funding for sub parts of the foundation and other efforts. Maybe this dilluted his claims a bit in time. All of his friends seemed to be pretty high grade researchers, it was a bit of an SF experiment sitting among that crowd.

Thanks for the name, there's another Kirkland studying aged things https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Kirkland_(paleontologist... but well .. couldn't resist that joke.

The panel I attended was the ICSA 2017 at Paris (Pasteur) http://www.icsa2017-senescence-on-the-seine.org/

Kirkland wasn't there but a nice international bunch

They were supposed to plan for a sequel since a few hundred people attended their surprise talk; we'll see.

Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by chrisseaton on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @11:17AM (#15132824)
I definitely think the UK system for PhDs is more focused and therefore more productive. On day one of my PhD my advisor showed me to my desk and told me to start researching what I wanted to research. I think in the US you do courses for years before you start actually researching, which is what you're there to do in the first place. And many US students seem to spend hours teaching.
Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by tnecniv on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @11:43AM (#15133076)
> I think in the US you do courses for years before you start actually researching, which is what you're there to do in the first place.

This varies a lot by program in the US. Some schools want you to take 10 classes in the first two years. You can, of course, do research but your mind will be elsewhere. Others don't care as long as you pass your quals and take the required number of courses by the end of your PhD.

Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by throwawayaway12 on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @11:44AM (#15133088)
>Doing a PhD in the UK helps, in and out before the funding dries up in 3-4 years is expected along with no class requirements and no masters needed (can go in straight from Bachelors)

I think this is the key sentence for a US perspective. 2 years of course work + 3 years of research for 5 years total is common in STEM fields.

[dead]
Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by nolite on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @01:08PM (#15133892)
Have you done PhD level research in either continent? This is utter horseshit...
Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by eanzenberg on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @05:42PM (#15136296)
Yes!
Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by vazamb on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @12:33PM (#15133535)
At least in Germany you need a masters to start a PhD and I think this is true for most of Europe. Actually, I always thought America is one of the few countries where you can start a PhD right out of undergrad.
Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by ylem on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @12:52PM (#15133729)
This is true in physics--I never bothered to get a masters along the route to getting my PhD
Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by joncrocks on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @12:09PM (#15133325)
Could you explain what you mean?

In terms of time spent? Level of knowledge in the subject area?

Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by kchoudhu on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @12:14PM (#15133375)
Americans tend to look down on anyone who has a doctorate from anywhere in Europe that isn't Oxford or Cambridge. I'm not sure it's justified, but there you go.
Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by Osmium on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @01:57PM (#15134393)
> Americans tend to look down on anyone who has a doctorate from anywhere in Europe that isn't Oxford or Cambridge.

Look, this just isn't true. I've heard it repeated a lot online, but I've never encountered it myself.

For context, I have a UK PhD, not from Oxford or Cambridge, and I got hired as a postdoc in a top-10 school in the US doing really exciting research.

There are differences between PhDs in US and the UK and Europe, but the differences are complex... there's no clear answer that one is better over the other.

It's a little unfortunate, because I've known Americans who were put off a UK-based PhD because they think professors look down on them, but I've seen little evidence to back it up. My colleagues come from all over the world, and they're all super smart, and everyone's treated equally and with respect. When it comes down to it, the quality of your research, and your ability to work hard, is far more important than what country or institution you're from.

(There are also a lot of anecdotes out there... in this thread, someone who completed early (congrats btw!), someone else with 20+ papers... you can be guaranteed there are people reading this thread who might be discouraged reading this. The one unifying factor with PhDs is that personal experience is highly variable, and artificial targets (finish in x years with y papers etc.) do not correlate with later success or the value of your research. So for anyone still slogging through who's reading this, good luck!)

Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by noir_lord on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @12:36PM (#15133571)
ETH Zurich would like a word with those folks.

It's the first university I think off for engineering, I mean they have 20 odd Nobel prizes from students and profs.

Not to mention the hundred or so other world class universities.

Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by chrisseaton on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @12:24PM (#15133458)
If you spent seven years doing something someone else did in three you're be bitter about it as well :)

I think the European approach is proved sound, since people do managed to produce top-tier publications in that time.

Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by ylem on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @01:21PM (#15134016)
I think the question is rather they are equivalent. For example, let's suppose someone does a quick PhD in 3 years, no masters, then all things being equal, they are likely to have less breadth than someone who took say 6 years (including masters). Exceptions abound. A rather difficult study might be to see how many postdocs a person with a 3 year PhD does compared to one with a longer PhD, or survivorship, but teasing out other factors would be a nightmare.
Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by beambot on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @02:36PM (#15134727)
> PhDs taking forever is generally a lack of initial work by the student rather than any external factors.

Not in my experience, especially for pre-tenured professors who are in an existential "publish or perish" scenario that defines their careers. It may sound harsh... but they invest a lot in their early students & lab setup, so their goal is to keep students around, publish as many papers as possible, and win enough grants as possible off their work before letting them graduate. I know plenty of folks who did thesis-level work in their first 2-3 years... but then their advisor made them keep grinding for another 2-3 years before "letting" them submit to committee.

Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by ylem on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @01:24PM (#15134052)
I want to second Xaa's point. When I was a PhD student, my advisor told me to enjoy the time because I was free from concerns like funding. We were poorly paid, but it was a good time to just be able to concentrate on research. It was common for people in my physics program to take 6 years to finish. But I wouldn't say that most of us "derped" around. During my PhD, I had a portfolio of projects--some that I thought had a high likelihood of success and others that could (and sometimes did) fail miserably.

As Xaa mentioned for NIH, there are clocks that start ticking after your PhD. This is true for other funding agencies as well. Also, when it's time to start hiring faculty, the fact that someone took 3 years vs 7 years for their PhD is not as important as their publication record and their plans for future research. We recently brought on a guy with 80+ publications (with a large number of those high impact) during his PhD and one postdoc.

I think "rushing" to finish isn't a worthwhile goal (even though I will admit that when I was a student, the stipend was horribly low, so there was a huge opportunity cost for those who decided to do something else later). Being productive during your time is worthwhile. Asking yourself if you are still being productive or if it's time to move on is productive. Not being a technician during your PhD is worthwhile. In that sense, the article has some good advice about taking time out to think. But, in some fields you sometimes just have to grind it out. Say for example, someone is doing an x-ray experiment at a synchotron, or doing MBE synthesis, there are times you just have to put in the hours to get results.

Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by kcorbitt on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @12:33PM (#15133530)
> Doing a PhD in the UK helps, in and out before the funding dries up in 3-4 years is expected along with no class requirements and no masters needed (can go in straight from Bachelors).

This is a key point. My wife's university in the UK actively tried to get its PhD candidates in and out in 3 years (with an optional 4th year for writing, typically part-time), and more than half of her cohort achieved that. While it's possible to get through a US PhD that fast, the norm is much longer. My wife's PhD is in biomedical materials.

Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by kchoudhu on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @12:13PM (#15133369)
This is generally why I think it's a good idea for undergraduates to get a couple of years of work experience in before returning for their PhDs: the experience of grinding out work that you really don't want to be doing is salutary and acts as motivation to get on with things once in the program.
Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by closed on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @11:25AM (#15132911)
It seems like early PhD work often involves working at a critical piece that's often overlooked: learning the social landscape of academics (and maybe figuring out what kind of academic they want to be).
Re:PhD Productivity Strategy: Do Deep Work in Less Hours by _raoulcousins on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @12:09PM (#15133326)
I don't want to generalize to others, because a PhD can be a really painful experience, but you got me spot on. I wasn't willing to iterate and try enough paths forward until one stuck. I'm still not sure why that was, because it seems obvious now and I saw others doing it right, but there was a lot of wasted time.