Re:Don’t Fall for Babylonian Trigonometry Hype
by coldtea on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @11:31AM
(#15132963)
>Post-euclidean geometers did not claim that Euclid was wrong, but if the article is to be believed, this guy is saying everyone else is wrong, apparently with arguments that are sketchy at best.
When everybody else believed that euclidean geometry was the only one possible, someone that insisted otherwise would also be labelled a crank (and he would be right in calling others wrong).
Re:Don’t Fall for Babylonian Trigonometry Hype
by mannykannot on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @12:27PM
(#15133484)
You are making an invalid comparison here. In your possibly hypothetical example (were the founders of non-euclidean geometry dismissed as cranks by their peers?) your lone post-euclidean would be justified in calling the others wrong for dismissing his mathematics, and also justified in denying their claim that Euclidean geometry was the only geometry, but he would be wrong if he were to say that Euclidean geometry itself was wrong. Wildberger is doing the equivalent of the latter, apparently.
I am sure you understand that being labeled a crank is not evidence of actually having greater insight. Instead of arguing from a dubious analogy of uncertain applicability, you would be much more convincing if you first took the specific objections to Wildberger's position from the article, and refuted them.
He is not being called a blasphemer, he is being dismissed with reasons. There is a difference.