News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Quebec reaches lodging tax deal with Airbnb by branchless on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @09:03PM (#15128930)
I agree with you, just check out this map of all the leeches:

http://insideairbnb.com/montreal/?neighbourhood=C%C3%B4te-de...

And this is not even central. Hopefully they all get their fingers badly burned when rates rise, this tax comes in and equity drops.

I'm very disappointed to hear this. Quebec is one of the last places in the Western world where rentiers have a hard time.

Also for people saying these are "for a few weekends".

Many AirBnb are not "a few weekends" they are a second home bought / mortgaged for the express purpose of permanently letting in out on airbnb and not paying tax.

Here you go: http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/quebec-airbnb-law-not...

Re:Quebec reaches lodging tax deal with Airbnb by cgmg on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @09:19PM (#15128998)
There's a great irony in calling renters "leeches" while trying to forcibly interfere between them and their customers to get a bigger cut of the transaction.
Re:Quebec reaches lodging tax deal with Airbnb by branchless on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @09:24PM (#15129027)
They are leeches and we should tax rentiers. Tax them out of existence. Or as near as we can get.

As Keynes said the euthanasia of the rentier, the functionless "investor" is to be welcomed.

edit: to the poster below

Many airbnb are not people "renting on a weekend when they go on holiday". It's a mini hotel. The former I don't mind, the latter should be taxed out of existence.

Your comment about groceries is dire. Production of food is elastic. Production of land is not. Taxing those who simply try to be middle men to be, yes, a rentier is a good thing. Not to take a cut but to get rid of them.

So many bad comments on HN that fail to understand elasticity and how prices are set. I'm off.

Re:Quebec reaches lodging tax deal with Airbnb by cgmg on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @10:16PM (#15129242)
> Many airbnb are not people "renting on a weekend when they go on holiday". It's a mini hotel. The former I don't mind, the latter should be taxed out of existence.

1. What percentage of Airbnb users belong to each category? Why do you ignore the former and hope 'they all get their fingers badly burned when rates rise'?

2. You still have provided no argument as to why the latter should be 'taxed out of existence'.

> Your comment about groceries is dire. Production of food is elastic. Production of land is not.

This is irrelevant to the point you and I were discussing, namely, that restricting the supply of something will not magically lower its price. It works just as well with any other supply-inelastic good or service.

> Taxing those who simply try to be middle men to be, yes, a rentier is a good thing.

Can you clarify what you mean by 'those who simply try to be middle men'?

> So many bad comments on HN that fail to understand elasticity and how prices are set. I'm off.

1. It's a bit ironic for you to make this accusation when you're literally advocating for taxing an entire economic sector 'out of existence'.

2. I made no comments about elasticity of supply. You did.

Re:Quebec reaches lodging tax deal with Airbnb by cgmg on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @09:54PM (#15129155)
Uh... Keynes never said we should tax people who rent their homes out of existence. That idea is quite nonsensical and counterproductive from an economic point of view. It's like saying we should tax groceries out of existence to reduce food prices.
Re:Quebec reaches lodging tax deal with Airbnb by mark_edward on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @02:20AM (#15130053)
Keynes did actually say the rentier class should be liquidated. The landlord is the ideal rentier. A grocer is not necessarily a rentier, they add value by providing a service. Rental income is purely a privilege of ownership, received due to a granted title, similar to patent and copyright.
Re:Quebec reaches lodging tax deal with Airbnb by branchless on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @07:27AM (#15131219)
It's okay he's writing on hacker news, where economics goes to die.
Re:Quebec reaches lodging tax deal with Airbnb by cgmg on Wednesday August 30, 2017 @11:55AM (#15133187)
I'll repeat what I said: Keynes never said we should tax people who rent their homes 'out of existence'. To imply otherwise is disingenuous.

I find it bizarre that you think renting out your home doesn't count as a 'service'. It certainly is a service by any reasonable definition of the word (including the one economists use).

Re:Quebec reaches lodging tax deal with Airbnb by cgmg on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @09:12PM (#15128965)
You think the solution to high rent prices is to reduce the number of renters and restrict the supply of properties available for rent?

Someone wasn't paying attention in econ class.

Re:Quebec reaches lodging tax deal with Airbnb by branchless on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @09:20PM (#15129003)
Econ 101 sucks. But you contradict yourself as econ 101 always states supply and demand.

AirBnb is for short-term rentals only. It does not target people in Montreal looking for 12 month rolling tenancies. But it does reduce supply as landlords move from supplying 12 month places to airbnb.

If we made life harder for airbnb supply would go up of rentals for families. Or landlords would sell up reducing prices and allowing families who presently rent to buy.

Yes there are some people on hacker news who just want to get their 200k and not have to worry about commitment. I don't care about them, they can sort themselves out. I want access for families to local schools.

The people offering this "service" just want to make a quick buck for very little work. They bring nothing to the community and make life harder for many families.

Re:Quebec reaches lodging tax deal with Airbnb by cgmg on Tuesday August 29, 2017 @09:50PM (#15129133)
> Econ 101 sucks.

?

> But you contradict yourself as econ 101 always states supply and demand.

Your sentence is incomprehensible. Please explain how I'm contradicting myself.

> AirBnb is for short-term rentals only. It does not target people in Montreal looking for 12 month rolling tenancies. But it does reduce supply as landlords move from supplying 12 month places to airbnb. If we made life harder for airbnb supply would go up of rentals for families. Or landlords would sell up reducing prices and allowing families who presently rent to buy.

Why should we favor 12-month rentees at the expense of the rest of society, to the point of forcing everyone else out?

> They bring nothing to the community and make life harder for many families.

I know right? They've brought absolutely nothing of value to the millions of customers who use their service. That's why they keep using it, of course!