News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Disagreeing with Paul Graham by stcredzero on Monday March 31, 2008 @02:12PM (#151242)
>When you break it down, Graham's argument from evolution goes like this: our ancestors worked in groups of eight or so, therefore humans evolved to work in groups of eight or so, therefore contemporary humans will be more alive and fulfilled working in groups of eight or so.

>In a general sense, this is the logical fallacy known as the "appeal to nature" -- the idea that what's natural is ipso facto good or right. There is no reason to believe this: plenty of natural things are neither good nor right.

Paul is not saying that working in groups of about 8 is not "good or right." He's saying that it's satisfying and functional. It's perfectly reasonable to say that something we were evolved to do is something we do well, and something we were not evolved to do, we have trouble with.

Re:Disagreeing with Paul Graham by serhei on Monday March 31, 2008 @08:30PM (#151566)
Satisfying and functional is good and right. Are you prepared to argue otherwise?
Re:Disagreeing with Paul Graham by stcredzero on Tuesday April 01, 2008 @08:12AM (#151937)
Satisfying and functional is often good and right, but in my personal system, it is sometimes not.

I could start cheating on my girlfriend pretty easily, but that would not be "good and right" to me, though it would arguably be satisfying and functional for me. Sometimes it seems satisfying and functional for me to punch people in the face. The problem with "satisfying and functional" = "good and right" is that both sides of that equation are highly complex, contextual, and subjective.

Re:Disagreeing with Paul Graham by serhei on Tuesday April 01, 2008 @08:40AM (#151950)
Surely that doesn't mean that in your earlier comment being a startup founder is satisfying and functional in a way that is not good and right.
Re:Disagreeing with Paul Graham by stcredzero on Tuesday April 01, 2008 @10:12AM (#152012)
Nope. It's neutral.