News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple drops Consumer Reports/iPhone 4 discussion threads by gojomo on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @03:12PM (#1512412)
Also, HN kills many threads with complaints about HN.

It's the prerogative and even duty of a forum proprietor to steer discussion in productive directions, given the goals of the forum. Proprietors aren't obligated to let a culture of complaint take hold, or provide a soapbox for all their implacable critics.

Sure, certain actions will appear to be -- or actually be -- heavy-handed and counterproductive. But some control is definitely better than none. It's a matter of choosing the right amount, while occasionally over- or under-shooting.

There are plenty of places to hear about the CR review, or bitch about Apple and its products -- Apple's own forums don't need to be one those places.

Re:Apple drops Consumer Reports/iPhone 4 discussion threads by joe_the_user on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @04:08PM (#1512551)
Evidence?

Threads get modded down but that's a bit different.

Re:Apple drops Consumer Reports/iPhone 4 discussion threads by gojomo on Tuesday July 13, 2010 @04:15PM (#1512581)
Make sure you have 'showdead' on in your preferences. You'll see occasional flare-ups of whiny or repetitive threads all [dead]-ed. One recent series was a bunch of "why did thread X get killed?" "why did the question about thread X get killed?" etc.

You'll also see what looks like arbitrary [dead]ing of plausibly topical submissions -- and with what appears to be HN preference against offering explanations or answering questions, people are left guessing why. Sometimes I think it's just that a few users who like to use flags-as-downvotes wander by at a time, triggering an auto-[dead], and then no attentive admin is sufficiently motivated to reverse the decision. (A bunch of submissions and comments that seemed harmless to me were [dead]ed over the July 4 weekend, perhaps because more surly flaggers than magnanimous admins were online.)

Also, I find it ironic that people are downvoting my defense of forum-moderation. Don't they realize their downvotes are -- by causing my comment to fade and drop out of view -- censoring me?

Hypocritical basterds! :)

edit: added 2nd paragraph with more anecdotal examples