News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:North Korea Missile Appears to Have Flown Over Japan, Abe... by patates on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:48PM (#15120353)
Don't most countries (especially the neighbors to those with violent tendencies) have automatic defenses against missiles? If Japan has such a system, did it fail to trigger? I just find it very weird that a missile would be able to pass across a country uninterrupted.
Re:North Korea Missile Appears to Have Flown Over Japan, Abe... by freehunter on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:56PM (#15120412)
Shooting down a missile with another missile is very difficult, especially if it's an ICBM moving at full speed.

Couple that with the fact that Hokkaido is as far north as you can get in Japan (as far from Tokyo and other major population centers further south, so there may not be missile defense systems there. Israel's Iron Dome only has a range of 70km, so I doubt, even if Japan had better technology, that they'd have one of these set up everywhere across the islands.

Being that Hokkaido is so far north, if you look on a map it's very very close to Russia. Not knowing the exact trajectory that it took, it's plausible that it went over Japanese airspace but was obviously not on a trajectory to impact the island itself. The article doesn't say where it was headed, just that it was in Japanese "airspace", and that it landed off the coast.

So plenty of reasons why it wasn't shot down. I'll add one more: the last thing you want to do is try to shoot down a test rocket and fail. Because if you fail on the test, the enemy will be more willing to believe you'd fail on the real thing, too.

Re:North Korea Missile Appears to Have Flown Over Japan, Abe... by kuschku on Monday August 28, 2017 @06:26PM (#15120648)
NHK just reported on TV it passed directly over Hokkaido, but landed 1200km straight east of Hokkaido in the sea.
Re:North Korea Missile Appears to Have Flown Over Japan, Abe... by clarkmoody on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:50PM (#15120373)
If the missile were on a ballistic trajectory that would not impact anywhere on land, perhaps it's better to let it fly on over into the ocean?

Shooting it down could reveal anti-missile capabilities that may be saved for a more serious impact threat.

Re:North Korea Missile Appears to Have Flown Over Japan, Abe... by patates on Monday August 28, 2017 @06:02PM (#15120470)
This makes total sense. Well, unless the missile makes an unexpected turn :) Are there any past examples of such "tests"? I couldn't figure out how to google it.
Re:North Korea Missile Appears to Have Flown Over Japan, Abe... by khuey on Monday August 28, 2017 @06:19PM (#15120587)
Unlike a cruise missile, ballistic missiles are not really capable of turning in that way.
Re:North Korea Missile Appears to Have Flown Over Japan, Abe... by rroriz on Monday August 28, 2017 @05:51PM (#15120379)
Maybe NK had this exact same question
Re:North Korea Missile Appears to Have Flown Over Japan, Abe... by MBCook on Monday August 28, 2017 @08:37PM (#15121309)
Even if you have a perfectly effective system you have to deal with the fact that when you shoot a missile down debris is going to fall. If you shoot a nuclear missile down, nuclear debris is going to fall.

Depending on where the missile is projected to land it might be a better idea not to shoot it.

Re:North Korea Missile Appears to Have Flown Over Japan, Abe... by dboreham on Monday August 28, 2017 @06:00PM (#15120450)
You don't want to unnecessarily expose the capabilities of your countermeasures. So no ABM launch unless absolutely necessary.