News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Lessons learned from implementing a text editor related t... by jasode on Monday August 28, 2017 @10:35AM (#15116777)
>I'm upset (really upset this morning) about the tone he/she and others here have toward someone who is exploring new CS idea [...] It just makes me sad to think that "Hacker News" is so down on someone who seems to be the prototypical curious hacker

I totally understand your frustration.

This 17 or 18-year-old[1] didn't meet mmjaa's standards[2] to write about programming and apparently, many HN'ers feel the same way.

Maybe that's how the majority of HN community wants it to be. I honestly don't know.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15116484

[2] a common "get off my lawn!" type of sentiment[1]: "To me, the "Full Stack" developer is simply someone who cares about whats happening under the hood. The "millennial developers" simply don't." -- https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14990097

Re:Lessons learned from implementing a text editor related t... by mmjaa on Monday August 28, 2017 @11:45AM (#15117347)
> exploring new CS ideas and techniques

The point is, this isn't a "new CS idea and technique" - in fact, this technique is as old as computer UI's themselves.

I have no idea how old this developer is, my only issue is that there is a re-invention of terminology and a whole new ontology being defined here, for something that has been a stock-standard CompSci concept for decades.

Its one thing to call me out as a grumpy old fart "not on my lawn"-ist - but its another thing to call out people who constantly re-invent the wheel and give it a new coat of paint, too. That is really my only motivation: to indicate that there is very little to be gained, productively, from ignoring the lessons of the past, "re-discovering" something, then slapping a new label on it. This doesn't do our industry any good - yet the practice is rampant. It seems, ever generation of CompSci graduates or so, someone gets the idea to invent something cool, which they've never heard of before, and proclaim that it is a unique insight into the field - whereas the fact is, its just a new coat of paint over an empty hole where the understanding should be.

We go through this psychosis every 4 or 5 years or so, in the computer world - so many times, we've re-invented the wheel and given it a new lick o' paint, calling it cool. I would, personally, like to see a bit more care given to this aspect of things by newcomers to this field - and rest assured, you can sit on my lawn as long as you cut it first.