Minor nitpick, but note that if you define:
(defun foo () (values))
Then (foo) does not return a value and accordingly, the REPL prints nothing. But in a context where you need a value, that value would be NIL: if A evaluates to 3, then after (setf a (foo)) it will evaluate to NIL.Though Common Lisp adds the nuance of multiple values, the behavior you describe is how it conforms to this general expectation. Code written in an everything-really-has-one-value dialect of Lisp can be easily transported to Common Lisp (or at least transported without without difficulties specifically caused by this issue).
Scheme, a Lisp-like language, allows some evaluable expressions to have an "undefined" or "unspecified" result value. Logic translated to Scheme from a Lisp dialect without attention to this issue can have a surprising or incorrect behavior. For instance, if the original code executes a do loop, with the expectation that it yields nil (or some similar false/empty value in the original dialect). In Scheme's do loop, if the result expression is present then it specifies the value; otherwise the value is not specified.
That's why they are heretics !!
(Just joking of course... Scheme is the other great Lisp dialect.)
The SBCL and CCL REPLs do not support readline-style editing. This actually makes them infuriating to use outside of Emacs or some other IDE-like environment. There is definitely a market for a high-quality, implementation-independent Lisp REPL.
TL;DR: I fail to see how this can be a problem.
Yes, but they do work fine inside Emacs (or perhaps inside other IDEs), and if i was using the SBCL command-line and needed readline-style-editing, then it was because I'm developing or debugging, so I'd be inside Emacs (or other IDE) in the first place...
(As noted before, REPL is a Lisp term that stands for:
read - from keyboard input, parse the input string into the syntactic structure of the language
eval - eval the expression, this includes binding variables or defining new functions, also re-defining functions, even if such function is currently under execution on the running program.
print - print the result of the evaluation (in Lisp all expressions evaluate to something, even if this 'something' is NIL).
loop - go to 'read')