For myself, it's fairly rare that I find myself way off from the critical consensus. I'm more likely to not care for big box office action films but, then, these aren't usually at the top of critics lists either.
Recommendations is a really tough problem even within a fairly narrow problem domain like film or music. I find Amazon and Netflix to mostly be pretty bad and you can be sure they've invested heavily.
Tastes do vary; I think it's fair to say that the average theatergoer has somewhat different tastes than I do.
But. If I read reviews of the critics at the major pubs and go to the movies they recommend, I may see some films that aren't to my tastes--just the sort of thing I KNOW isn't going to be my bag going in--and I may miss a few I'd really enjoy. But it's not a bad filter. And many of the people I know have relatively similar tastes.
Maybe that just means I'm of a similar demographic and have similar tastes to many critics. There does seem to be some consensus though.
BTW this is my shared ranking: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1ojCTmnu8-uIXxnas142M...
EDIT: changed 7.6 to 76 based on the comment below.