Re:Fun vs. Computer Science (2016)
by mbrock on Saturday August 26, 2017 @07:07AM
(#15104963)
Can you expand on what is meant by algorithms and computing, and what you mean that computers mostly do instead?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Fun vs. Computer Science (2016)
by vanderZwan on Saturday August 26, 2017 @07:31AM
(#15105016)
The skill of programming is really about translating tasks that are semantically meaningful to humans (ie making a user friendly online booking site for a hotel) into "meaningless" instructions that can be computed by a turing complete machine. That's very different from, say, deriving a faster partition algorithm by using half-swaps instead of full swaps (as demonstrated by Andrei Alexandrescu last year).
Re:Fun vs. Computer Science (2016)
by Karrot_Kream on Saturday August 26, 2017 @09:06AM
(#15105255)
But aren't all forms of engineering about translating semantically meaningful tasks into {problem-domain}? What makes software different?
"...into "meaningless" instructions that can be computed by a turing complete machine."
Pssst! Hey, buddy, that's what an algorithm is.
Computers today mostly (a) communicate and (b) store/retrieve data.
Both at the macro level, what they are used for, but also at the micro level. Actual computation tends to be incidental.
Yet you can't just tell the computer to communicate or do I/O -- it's all controlled by decisions, and making those decisions is basically what I call computation.
Yep...incidental computation. Also: "primarily"/"mostly". Not all/none.
Hmm, maybe a lot of computation is outsourced to server farms, but "clients" still do a lot of it: image processing, codecs, scheduling, layout, speech recognition, etc etc.
So what are codecs for? Communication, storage.
What is speech recognition for? Communication.
etc.
I think you keep arguing against something I never said, which is that computers do no computing whatsoever.