News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rules for new FPGA designers by adwn on Saturday August 26, 2017 @01:19AM (#15104193)
I studied computer science and taught myself FPGA design on my own.

The thing is, implementing non-trivial FPGA designs is much closer to software development than to analog hardware design, both in the problem-solving approaches and in the tools you use (text-based languages instead of schematics); a "low-level mindset" is necessary, though. The association of FPGAs with electrical engineering is mostly due to historical reasons.

As for learning FPGA design: Download the free Xilinx Vivado Webpack (or the Intel/Altera equivalent), it is so feature-complete that it's even sufficient for many commercial designs. Most online tutorials (and university courses) are pretty crap though, because the teach you extremely low-level approaches, like building your own adders, which you should never do in FPGAs. This is great for understanding bit-level arithmetic, but useless for approaching and partitioning larger problems. It's the equivalent of teaching someone assembly (great for understanding the inner operations of a CPU), and then asking them to implement a webserver.

Besides, most online tutorials and university courses teach outdated coding styles, like separating sequential and combinational processes. It's good to read, e.g., the Xilinx forums to stay up-to-date.

There are no comments on this comment yet.