Re:Good News for Young Strivers: Networking Is Overrated
by mjw1007 on Friday August 25, 2017 @02:29PM
(#15100947)
I agree: the article may well be right that a cold-calling style of 'networking' doesn't do much, but it doesn't seem to have anything to suggest that the good oldfashioned "having the right parents" kind is no good.
Re:Good News for Young Strivers: Networking Is Overrated
by ghaff on Friday August 25, 2017 @03:41PM
(#15101561)
I think that's about right. I periodically get something along the lines of "I'm one of the 50,000 people who went to one of the same schools you did and I'm interested in a job at your company." I might exchange some info but I'm certainly not going to bat for someone I have a very peripheral connection with.
On the other hand, every job I've gotten since school has been very directly through someone I had worked with in some manner and knew well. In none of the cases did I go through a standard application process.
Re:Good News for Young Strivers: Networking Is Overrated
by tejaswidp on Friday August 25, 2017 @02:25PM
(#15100918)
Why do you think PhD is a waste of time?
Re:Good News for Young Strivers: Networking Is Overrated
by a-saleh on Friday August 25, 2017 @02:38PM
(#15101023)
I would say that PHD is not a waste of time only if you plan to stay in academia. If writing papers and chasing grants is your jam, go for it.
If you are looking for one more thing for your CV, don't bother with phd.
Re:Good News for Young Strivers: Networking Is Overrated
by busterarm on Friday August 25, 2017 @02:44PM
(#15101070)
Degree-less person here and vehemently disagree. Maybe across the field in general, but some of the most interesting areas of work have Ph.Ds and/or significant levels of domain experience as gatekeepers.
Re:Good News for Young Strivers: Networking Is Overrated
by likelynew on Saturday August 26, 2017 @11:23AM
(#15105821)
No one is denying that. People are talking about return on investment for an average Ph.D. vs masters or things like that.
Re:Good News for Young Strivers: Networking Is Overrated
by a-saleh on Saturday August 26, 2017 @06:02AM
(#15104831)
Like? I have always thought that master degree with some domain experience trumps PhD.
Re:Good News for Young Strivers: Networking Is Overrated
by robotresearcher on Friday August 25, 2017 @02:43PM
(#15101063)
The main reason to do a PhD is for your own personal drive and satisfaction. Unless you value the work for its own sake, it is unlikely to pay off.
Re:Good News for Young Strivers: Networking Is Overrated
by binarysolo on Friday August 25, 2017 @08:34PM
(#15103399)
Even better: get into the PhD program and then drop out. You have all the signalling of being selected in a fancy PhD, but it also shows that you're practical and interested in work and industry.
Anec-data: me and several other PhD folks who all dropped out of CS/Stats/ML and got plenty of offers for jobs and funding. :)
Re:Good News for Young Strivers: Networking Is Overrated
by VygmraMGVl on Friday August 25, 2017 @10:24PM
(#15103723)
How do you properly signal that you dropped out of a PhD program to distinguish yourself from someone with a Masters?
Re:Good News for Young Strivers: Networking Is Overrated
by a-saleh on Saturday August 26, 2017 @06:04AM
(#15104834)
Maybe having few good papers/conference talks?
Re:Good News for Young Strivers: Networking Is Overrated
by johan_larson on Friday August 25, 2017 @08:23PM
(#15103346)
Generally speaking, you should get the qualifications you need for the job you want. If you want to be a software developer or program manager, a B.Sc. is sufficient and a PhD is overkill and a waste of time. If you want to be an academic or a scientist in industry, a PhD is essentially required.
Re:Good News for Young Strivers: Networking Is Overrated
by bitL on Friday August 25, 2017 @02:39PM
(#15101033)
...unless you are in Europe, where it's an almost required gate to upper management.
Re:Good News for Young Strivers: Networking Is Overrated
by gaius on Friday August 25, 2017 @05:43PM
(#15102468)
Only in Germany, certainly not in the UK - here Eton trumps PhD every day of the week.
Re:Good News for Young Strivers: Networking Is Overrated
by bitL on Friday August 25, 2017 @07:30PM
(#15103070)
I probably should have written in German-speaking countries.
I never understood the "reputation" component in the UK education that also made it to QS rankings where Oxbridge are propelled by near perfect reputation while lacking in other, more-academic categories.
Re:Good News for Young Strivers: Networking Is Overrated
by gaius on Saturday August 26, 2017 @02:25AM
(#15104332)
Coincidentally I wrote a comment that explains it the other day https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15088782
Re:Good News for Young Strivers: Networking Is Overrated
by enraged_camel on Friday August 25, 2017 @06:46PM
(#15102876)
Nah. Many high tech fields in the private sector recruit PhDs for research positions. Intel for example has a ton of them.
Nowadays, when I get a chance to mentor younglings my main point is that networking is a HUGE part of success (other important point being not to waste time on a PhD, but that's another topic). As with any effort you have to learn how to do it, of course. Harassing people for their contact info, etc. is a networking anti pattern.