News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:9th Circuit Guts "First Sale" Rights by tzs on Monday July 12, 2010 @12:16PM (#1508382)
I don't think they are gutting anything. They are simply trying to work around the Supreme Court's botched decision in Quality King.

Until I read Quality King, I had no idea that the section 6xx limitations on importing had any connection to the section 1xx exceptions to 17 USC 106. And I doubt that Congress had any idea there was a connection, either.

The 9th Circuit is trying to find a way to read section 109 so as to undo Quality King and get back to what Congress intended--unauthorized importation of copyrighted works, other than for personal use, is prohibited.

Re:9th Circuit Guts "First Sale" Rights by _delirium on Monday July 12, 2010 @02:04PM (#1508783)
So the intended meaning is that a used-book store in Amsterdam can't sell a batch of books to a used-book store in NYC without individually contacting each of the books' copyright holders and asking for their permission to import the book?
Re:9th Circuit Guts "First Sale" Rights by narrator on Monday July 12, 2010 @02:36PM (#1508895)
The idea is that the multi-nationals can sell stuff to third worlders at near cost to build market share or comply with price controls and mark up 500% in another country to take advantage of subsidies, medicare reimbursements, perceived brand "value", or on-the-sly price collusion with other vendors and no screwy small fry grey market traders can get in the way of their "marketing policies".
Re:9th Circuit Guts "First Sale" Rights by dantheman on Monday July 12, 2010 @03:02PM (#1509003)
Yep, in other words it's bullshit.
Re:9th Circuit Guts "First Sale" Rights by nhebb on Monday July 12, 2010 @02:27PM (#1508869)
the Supreme Court's botched decision in Quality King

The footer of the Supreme Court ruling says it was a unanimous decision. More than likely, the problem lies in how the law was written, not in how it was interpreted.

Re:9th Circuit Guts "First Sale" Rights by chc on Monday July 12, 2010 @09:33PM (#1510080)
You've gotten distracted by the handwaving and forgotten that the "copyrighted work" here is essentially a wristwatch. Specifically, they're talking about the logo they put on the wristwatch, but to argue that a logo on an item brings the whole item under copyright law is madness.
Re:9th Circuit Guts "First Sale" Rights by wjy on Monday July 12, 2010 @10:37PM (#1510178)
It's especially mad since there's no copying taking place at all.
Re:9th Circuit Guts "First Sale" Rights by CamperBob on Monday July 12, 2010 @04:14PM (#1509249)
The 9th Circuit is trying to find a way to read section 109 so as to undo Quality King and get back to what Congress intended--unauthorized importation of copyrighted works, other than for personal use, is prohibited.

Because a wristwatch is a copyrighted work.