News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nuclear fusion is on the brink of a milestone, but faces ... by Retric on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @12:30PM (#15082863)
Sounds like they are ignoring a huge swath of problems.

So yes, with a lot of effort you could design a smaller and less expensive to construct structure assuming higher field strengths, but it would take massive amounts of time and R&D to get to that point.

IMO, we really just need to bite the bullet and build something at scale. Version 1 needs not be efficient, but it's going to teach us a lot more about operations than simulations can.

Re:Nuclear fusion is on the brink of a milestone, but faces ... by DennisP on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @02:49PM (#15084062)
Reactors similar to MIT's ARC proposal have been built in about four years. You can do more experiments, do them faster, and since it's so much cheaper you can do more of them and take more risks. Speeding up progress is one of MIT's main objectives.
Re:Nuclear fusion is on the brink of a milestone, but faces ... by wcarss on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @03:38PM (#15084421)
building something _at scale_ is basically the approach ITER has taken, and there is a different kind of problem in it: people & project management at that scale are very tough. Maybe tougher than the engineering even is.

When you need many countries to smoothly co-operate on a many-billion-dollar decades-long project that's hard to swiftly articulate or grasp, let alone pivot, while technology and geopolitics swiftly shifts around you, you're going to have a bad time.

ARC with modern superconductors is in many ways ITER but capable of being built on a multi-university budget, by virtue of those superconductors being much more powerful while being much smaller and lightweight and operating closer to room-temperature. The whole reactor needed for the same energy scale a ITER is physically much smaller.

The PSFC at MIT (who is proposing this plan) built the last great tokamak that got us closest to real fusion back in the 90s and that inspired ITER. ITER was the best plan available after that: the project size was necessary given conditions at the outset. Now many people are committed to it, and we're many billions in, so it likely isn't going away.

But ARC is probably a better version of basically the same plan given today's outlook: a scaled up tokamak, doable at university, national-lab, or skunkworks-level project sizes.

So I believe we could see huge progress from this in the next 5 years.

The only thing I have not seen articulated in Zach Hartwig or Dennis Whyte's otherwise fantastic talks in the past year is: what's next? What are the concrete steps between today and some version of ARC? They don't seem to be raising money yet, so it is clear there are some open questions about the other innovations in the ARC design, and I want to hear how/when we expect those to be solved or at least well-defined.

Re:Nuclear fusion is on the brink of a milestone, but faces ... by Retric on Wednesday August 23, 2017 @07:04PM (#15085982)
The problem in my mind is ITER is not really viable to produce power at reasonable costs. To be useful it would need to produce something like 5GW of heat for similar costs. Thus, ARC needs to be more than 10X as good to avoid hitting ITER scale in production.
Re:Nuclear fusion is on the brink of a milestone, but faces ... by jlebrech on Friday August 25, 2017 @03:57AM (#15096908)
the wright brother's wooden plane isn't viable at long distances.