Re:Paul Buchheit: Ideas vs Judgment and Execution: Climbing ...
by Tichy on Monday March 31, 2008 @05:47AM
(#150903)
I think an "idea person" would by definition have more than one good idea. If as you say 99 great ideas are necessary to make it to the top, an idea person might be the right person for the project?
Many people don't seem to have any ideas at all, their whole inspiration for life comes from TV and magazines. I prefer idea people. Execution would be even better, of course. But why not talk to the idea people you know and help them execute?
Re:Paul Buchheit: Ideas vs Judgment and Execution: Climbing ...
by GavinB on Monday March 31, 2008 @01:48AM
(#150797)
This is why his point about judgment is right on. The challenge is not having good ideas but knowing which of your ideas are good.
When Paul Graham says that all that what they care about is having good people, there's an underlying assumption that good people won't pursue lousy ideas.
Ideas can't be sold, but judgment of what is a good idea can be profitable -- that's one of the things that venture capitalists do.
Re:Paul Buchheit: Ideas vs Judgment and Execution: Climbing ...
by greendestiny on Monday March 31, 2008 @01:20AM
(#150780)
I feel strongly the same way. That's why I think what you need for a startup is a kernel of idea generation. This kernel is in itself initially an idea, but the key function it has is to inspire quality after-ideas. I tend to have an initial idea, analyze it, and try to find some insight in it. If it works this insight, or way of looking at things, becomes an idea catalyst.
Really, what's execution other than all the ideas that you have after you've picked a direction?
That's why I'm skeptical of self-proclaimed "idea people". They tend to have one great idea and fixate upon it, not realizing that they've gotten maybe 1% of the way there, and need to think up 99 other great ideas before their one great idea is worthwhile.