- In a situation where all decent schools are oversubscribed swapping 100% encourages (and rewards) setting up your school list strategically. Which helps out families that have the time to collect the information needed and sort their schools appropriately (we spent a bunch of time researching / planning here, but knew off other families who _really_ got into gaming the system)
- In one of the meetings where the slide you linked in [1] was displayed, they offhand mentioned that the swapping order is done alphabetically. When asked if kids with A* names will get better swaps they kinda ignored the question and moved on. But how are multiple tied swaps resolved?
- Also, from what we were told, the swapping doesn't respect the "lottery weight" that locals, poor test score neighborhood kids, or siblings get. If that's important, shouldn't it apply to all phases of the process? (I'm aware the math here might get out of hand)
I started out thinking that the swapping was a good idea, but when I saw how much it encouraged and rewarded strategy in building the list of schools I changed my mind. It's not a fair process. It's a system that rewards families that have likely already been rewarded by society.
Doesn't that same reasoning apply to increasing the weight? Maybe it's so important and not more important.
[1] https://www.nytimes.com/2017/01/21/us/san-francisco-children...
A majority of students get their first choice public school.[1] However there is a lot of competition for a handful of the most desired schools. Only a small percentage of students request their local school first, but if you live near a popular school and you don't get it, it is frustrating. You may end up getting placed at a much less desirable school farther away. People blame the lottery for that, but ultimately the "best" schools don't have enough seats.
[1] http://www.sfusd.edu/en/assets/sfusd-staff/enroll/files/2015...
This way, if I want the Green party, and am willing to settle for Liberals, but can't stand the thought of a Conservative win, then I can support my favorite party without risking a split vote that lets the hated party squeak in with ~38% of the vote. Naturally, those of us who vote for fringe parties are strongly in favor of STV, and those who benefit from split votes complain that it is too complex for the average voter to understand.
It works more or less as described, where you list off all the schools you want in order of preference. It runs lotteries for each of them in parallel and you get the highest listed one you win. But then it does one more thing: If it finds mutually advantageous swaps, it does so automatically and instantly. In other words, it's not up to or necessary for the student to do it manually.
In fact this feature is detailed by the Ivy League team that put it together, including Alvin Roth, as early as 2010.[2] So while this article is well written it seems to give a less than complete picture. Why did Amsterdam not adopt this feature?
P.S. There is much to be said about the SF lottery system which is a fun / highly stressful topic for nerds and parents. If you like these kinds of problems I encourage you to take a look. It also tries to solve for giving preferences to neighborhood schools and disadvantaged families, while also offering special language and K-8 programs that serve the whole city fairly. The goal is to eliminate strategizing as much as possible, but it's very interesting to see people figure out some hacks.
[1] http://www.sfusd.edu/en/assets/sfusd-staff/enroll/files/2012...
[2] http://web.stanford.edu/~niederle/SFUSDBoardPresentationFeb....