News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Hate Groups Forced Online Platforms to Reveal Their T... by xienze on Monday August 21, 2017 @06:38PM (#15068352)
I know everyone is going to say "but Nazis", but I think this incident should really drive home just how quickly dissenting opinion can effectively be purged from the Internet and just how much power tech companies truly wield over us. Yeah yeah I know, it's great because they stood up to Nazis but next time it won't just be them. It's very easy to label just about anything as "hate speech".

And yeah yeah, "private companies can't censor, only the government can", but has anyone stopped to consider that Google et al have very obvious political affiliations and can exert their control over the Internet in order to further their agendas? If you're not concerned with the implications of this you're not paying attention.

Re:How Hate Groups Forced Online Platforms to Reveal Their T... by bilbo0s on Monday August 21, 2017 @06:41PM (#15068380)
"...but has anyone stopped to consider that Google et al have very obvious political affiliations and can exert their control over the Internet in order to further their agendas?..."

Have you, yourself, stopped to consider the possibility that large corporations have had very obvious political affiliations, and have been exerting their control to further their agendas since long before Google existed?

Re:How Hate Groups Forced Online Platforms to Reveal Their T... by xienze on Monday August 21, 2017 @06:44PM (#15068396)
Have you considered that Google, Facebook, etc. can control public discourse and what information people can see in ways never before thought possible?
Re:How Hate Groups Forced Online Platforms to Reveal Their T... by bilbo0s on Monday August 21, 2017 @06:48PM (#15068427)
Have you considered that advisers for Nixon's first Presidential campaign made the same complaint about network television?

My only point here is that many, many companies have been exerting their control for many, many years to further the varied agendas of their principal shareholders.

This really is nothing new.

Re:How Hate Groups Forced Online Platforms to Reveal Their T... by reaperducer on Monday August 21, 2017 @07:02PM (#15068514)
Not new. But better. More effective. Which is worse.
Re:How Hate Groups Forced Online Platforms to Reveal Their T... by stefs on Monday August 21, 2017 @07:18PM (#15068593)
more effective than the kronen-zeitung?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kronen_Zeitung

Re:How Hate Groups Forced Online Platforms to Reveal Their T... by laretluval on Monday August 21, 2017 @07:08PM (#15068542)
> have been exerting their control to further their agendas since long before Google existed?

It's an old idea that corporations control discourse to further their political agendas, but previously those agendas were hard to discern.

The new information that has become clear in the last few months, at least to me, is that their political agendas tend to be that of the Democratic party.

Re:How Hate Groups Forced Online Platforms to Reveal Their T... by purple-again on Monday August 21, 2017 @06:41PM (#15068379)
It's been part sad and part fun to watch. Usually they use pedophiles to convince us to give up our freedoms but nazis are working just as well this time around.
Re:How Hate Groups Forced Online Platforms to Reveal Their T... by dragonwriter on Monday August 21, 2017 @06:47PM (#15068421)
> I know everyone is going to say "but Nazis", but I think this incident should really drive home just how quickly dissenting opinion can effectively be purged from the Internet

Nazi/White Supremacist opinion is still all over the internet, so it doesn't seem to “effectively be purged”.

Re:How Hate Groups Forced Online Platforms to Reveal Their T... by tim333 on Monday August 21, 2017 @07:49PM (#15068724)
>how quickly dissenting opinion can effectively be purged from the Internet

I'm not sure it can be purged from the internet at all. It can be purged from some US companies but will pop up elsewhere.

To illustrate - ISIS site http://jihadology.net/

Buy illegal drugs online https://www.reddit.com/r/Dream_Market/comments/6v5ghq/whos_b...

etc. The internet is very hard to censor.

Re:How Hate Groups Forced Online Platforms to Reveal Their T... by Anon1096 on Monday August 21, 2017 @08:19PM (#15068834)
It can be done. Child porn (I'm in no way endorsing the viewing of it obviously) is extinct from the internet as we all know it. And when talking about smaller instances like the Daily Stormer it becomes clear that internet censorship is very real and very possible.
Re:How Hate Groups Forced Online Platforms to Reveal Their T... by mirimir on Monday August 21, 2017 @08:25PM (#15068850)
Freenet is part of the Internet, and it's full of child porn. Indeed, it's rather a honeypot for authorities to exploit. So much for plausible deniability.
Re:How Hate Groups Forced Online Platforms to Reveal Their T... by tim333 on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @06:00AM (#15070947)
Yeah, I was thinking with drugs, ISIS and child porn while the internet is almost impossible to censor, it's also not that great at protecting privacy with the result that the bad guys often get arrested or killed eventually.
Re:How Hate Groups Forced Online Platforms to Reveal Their T... by mirimir on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @02:19PM (#15075055)
Indeed. And that's Freenet's problem. It does a great job of obscuring locally stored content. The majority of data on your box may be child porn, but nobody can tell. However, Freenet relies on randomized request and data forwarding for deniability. That seemed reasonable, a decade ago.

But investigators have figured out how to determine that a particular node has handled pieces of a particular file. Not that the user loaded or requested the file. Just that their node handled part of it. And of course, IP addresses aren't obscured.

So investigators run nodes, and serve child porn. And then they accumulate IPs of peers that handle pieces of said child porn. And get subpoenas for those in their jurisdictions, and raid users. And have experts that bullshit juries about how Freenet works.

Understandably, most defendants settle. Except, for example, that guy who's rotting in a Philadelphia jail.

Re:How Hate Groups Forced Online Platforms to Reveal Their T... by mirimir on Monday August 21, 2017 @06:51PM (#15068441)
You can't expect any platform to provide free speech unless it's designed to make censorship impossible. Such as Freenet, or Tor onion services.

Edit: Here's the juicy quote:

> The recent rise of all-encompassing internet platforms promised something unprecedented and invigorating: venues that unite all manner of actors — politicians, media, lobbyists, citizens, experts, corporations — under one roof. These companies promised something that no previous vision of the public sphere could offer: real, billion-strong mass participation; a means for affinity groups to find one another and mobilize, gain visibility and influence. This felt and functioned like freedom, but it was always a commercial simulation.

Re:How Hate Groups Forced Online Platforms to Reveal Their T... by xienze on Monday August 21, 2017 @06:55PM (#15068473)
Didn't the Tor guys say they were going to do something about hate speech?
Re:How Hate Groups Forced Online Platforms to Reveal Their T... by mirimir on Monday August 21, 2017 @07:25PM (#15068624)
If they can, Tor is total bullshit. So no, I seriously doubt that they can. And that's, in my opinion, a very good thing.
Re:How Hate Groups Forced Online Platforms to Reveal Their T... by mirimir on Tuesday August 22, 2017 @02:06PM (#15074930)
Edit: OK, so Tor exits could filter on URLs, and even MitM TLS to filter on keywords. But that has always been forbidden, and grounds for the bad exit flag. Exits are allowed, and indeed encouraged, to block ports that are commonly abused. And unfortunately, more and more that includes port 22 :(
Re:How Hate Groups Forced Online Platforms to Reveal Their T... by 0x4f3759df on Monday August 21, 2017 @10:12PM (#15069218)
Plus the definition of "hate speech" is broad enough to include people who hold Biblical views on social issues which is not an insignificant portion of the American population.
Re:How Hate Groups Forced Online Platforms to Reveal Their T... by yongjik on Monday August 21, 2017 @06:56PM (#15068479)
> ...just how quickly dissenting opinion can effectively be purged from the Internet...

But not quick enough to keep them from electing a US president who they embrace as their own.

Really, there was nothing quick about it. It's more like watching the straw that finally broke the camel's back.