News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anger, Anxiety, Resentment, Stress, and Basic Humanity by Numberwang on Sunday August 20, 2017 @09:58AM (#15058411)
Mostly nonsense said with authority. Psychology and dietary advice really are crap sciences.
Re:Anger, Anxiety, Resentment, Stress, and Basic Humanity by Broken_Hippo on Sunday August 20, 2017 @10:13AM (#15058465)
So was medicine at one time... and all the rest. We got a lot of stuff wrong, and a few things right and built on that.

Psychology isn't all bad, since a lot more folks with severe mental illness can now go on to lead a much more normal life due to medication and coping mechanisms. Same for folks that go through trauma and have after-effects. But we are still refining this stuff, so some of it is going to be crap and there are going to be lots of pseudo-psychology fed to the uneducated masses.

Nutrition is somewhat similar. We simply don't have the knowledge to understand its complexities right now. But it isn't all crap: We understand connections between malnourishment and stunted growth, for example. Understand folic acid helps prevent birth defects and vitamin C helps prevent scurvy. To confound matters more, we have a lot of misinformation, partially due to politics and business practices. This isn't really confined to nutrition, though. Society is prone to reject new ways of thinking. Heck, the US pushed against modern "european-style" medicine back in the 1800's - they didn't think they needed science in their medicine or something like that.

Re:Anger, Anxiety, Resentment, Stress, and Basic Humanity by transman on Sunday August 20, 2017 @06:24PM (#15060548)
(I have an undergrad degree in Psychology.) Psychology has the means to be a proper science, but historically a significant amount of hasn't been. The examples you present tend to come from neuroscience, which in turn tends to be a much more empirically based field.

- http://www.nature.com/news/over-half-of-psychology-studies-f...

- https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/psychology-s-cred...

- https://digest.bps.org.uk/2017/05/25/was-the-crisis-in-socia...

Re:Anger, Anxiety, Resentment, Stress, and Basic Humanity by Broken_Hippo on Monday August 21, 2017 @05:59AM (#15063292)
Disclaimer: I've read the articles well because I just woke up, but I'll read have the read in a bit (I like the subject).

I do understand some of that, and probably see more of the psuedo-science application than most: there is a psychological model of occultism folks follow, some of it heavily leaning on Jung's work... who didn't have passable education that we'd like now. And that was pretty common for early psychology: It was more akin to basic philosophy and unbased theories than science.

But I realize that is changing and I realize the good the system really does - my ex was schizo-affective (though he got diagnosed with regular schizophrenia after we broke up). Without the whole system, both the stuff based on shaky psychology and the more pure medical portion with the meds and psychiatrist, he'd have died - no exaggeration.

Re:Anger, Anxiety, Resentment, Stress, and Basic Humanity by random_comment on Sunday August 20, 2017 @10:44AM (#15058573)
> Mostly nonsense said with authority. Psychology and dietary advice really are crap sciences.

You don't appear to have presented any evidence or reasons that would make your hostile opinions a useful contribution here.

Re:Anger, Anxiety, Resentment, Stress, and Basic Humanity by KirinDave on Sunday August 20, 2017 @11:35AM (#15058810)
It might have been true 25-30 years ago. While dietary advice may still be fraught with charlatans, the general quality of work in psychology has improved tremendously.

Methodologies have been devised, reproducible results have actually become an expectation, and psychology has benefited quite a bit from biology, computer science and information theory.

Re:Anger, Anxiety, Resentment, Stress, and Basic Humanity by Numberwang on Sunday August 20, 2017 @04:34PM (#15060132)
And with all this we get gems like 'surrendering to a higher power' Pathetic.
Re:Anger, Anxiety, Resentment, Stress, and Basic Humanity by KirinDave on Sunday August 20, 2017 @05:42PM (#15060387)
Like many other scientifically backed disiplines, people with other agendas co-opt the prestige of the space.
Re:Anger, Anxiety, Resentment, Stress, and Basic Humanity by virgil_disgr4ce on Sunday August 20, 2017 @10:45AM (#15058575)
What do you think is nonsense?
[dead]
Re:Anger, Anxiety, Resentment, Stress, and Basic Humanity by nkohari on Sunday August 20, 2017 @01:46PM (#15059374)
It appears you might be suffering from anger, anxiety, resentment, and/or stress.
Re:Anger, Anxiety, Resentment, Stress, and Basic Humanity by redcat7 on Sunday September 03, 2017 @07:35AM (#15160914)
It appears you might be suffering from not-your-fucking-bussines.
Re:Anger, Anxiety, Resentment, Stress, and Basic Humanity by ebcode on Sunday August 20, 2017 @05:24PM (#15060318)
You forgot basic humanity.
Re:Anger, Anxiety, Resentment, Stress, and Basic Humanity by manmal on Sunday August 20, 2017 @04:07PM (#15060015)
We are far from an altruistic society because we might count our friends, maybe neighbors, and, just maybe, people we see on the subway as part of our tribe. The rest of society is viewed as "the others" for whom we could care less, emotionally. We can be tricked into caring for them by emotional TV ads (poor kids in Africa need water or are blind) or reading books or watching documentaries about them (e.g. indigenious people, we want them to keep their habitat). But as long as nothing brings us "close" to others, they remain.. others.