News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:First Amendment in Peril? by throwaway0255 on Saturday August 19, 2017 @05:46AM (#15052564)
> Either a country accepts this within its legal framework and has e.g hate speech laws (e.g Germany) or it doesn't (e.g US), but in the latter case as being "outside" the law - and it must be met with force outside the law.

Or it could, you know, not be met with force outside the law, because we live in a civil society where people are free to think independently and express themselves, and we have laws against assaulting people.

Call me crazy.

I don't know when in my lifetime liberals pulled this 180 on freedom of speech, but seriously, it's causing me to do the hardest 180 of MY life right the fuck into being a conservative after spending the first 30 years of my life as a liberal.

What you just wrote is one of the craziest things I've ever read. You're directly calling for and praising violence against people based on their ideas and beliefs and how they choose to non-violently express them. Just 10 years ago you'd be booed by every liberal in the nation and rightfully regarded as an anti-intellectual, a book burner, or a fascist.

My whole life, liberals were so proud to declare that they defend their opposition's right to speech even though they don't agree with it. When did this change?

Re:First Amendment in Peril? by Broken_Hippo on Saturday August 19, 2017 @06:07AM (#15052608)
"When did this change?"

When we grew up and realized that no, people really shouldn't be marching the street calling for genocide or calling for other groups to be treated as animals. When we realized it is bad to harass others, by surrounding them with torches and yelling racist slurs or by burning freaking crosses in someone else's yard.

When we realized that we don't actually want to spread hate and convince others to think the same.

This won't stop folks from thinking this or spreading it to some extent, but there isn't a reason we have to give them space in the public sphere, with marches on public roads obviously meant for everybody, regardless of background. Nor does an employer have any need to respect the right of their employee to spread hate, a web hosting service to host the websites, and other such things.

Another thing we've realized as we've grown up is that one cannot both protect freedom of speech like this and have any true means of actually overcoming it. This puts actual goals like equality and a more fair society at risk.

And above all, it changed when folks re-thought "Fuck Nazis and Fight them".

Of course, this is all just speaking from the top of my head and nothing in here is known fact without someone factchecking it, as I have not.

Re:First Amendment in Peril? by chrisco255 on Saturday August 19, 2017 @06:18AM (#15052625)
You fight bad ideas with reason and persuasion. Period. If someone does something illegal, you get the authorities involved. Speech is protected, even "offensive" speech. Civics 101.
Re:First Amendment in Peril? by alkonaut on Saturday August 19, 2017 @07:12AM (#15052761)
Their speech is protected as legal (in the US, might vary elsewhere).

What I was getting at is that their platform is not guaranteed. They must be shut down, their speech drowned. Non-violent protest as long as possible, violent only as a last resort. But you don't let nazis speak and shrug and say "it's their right, let's hear them, try to convince them they are wrong".

Re:First Amendment in Peril? by throwaway0255 on Saturday August 19, 2017 @01:11PM (#15054427)
We live in a country where people will label you a nazi for thinking voters should have to provide ID, or that we should enforce border laws or have a border at all, or that capitalism is preferable to socialism.

This is precisely WHY we have freedom of speech as an absolute in this country. Because once you empower people to attack hate speech, the definition of "hate speech" will invariably be expanded and abused in ways that are totalitarian and fascistic, which is EXACTLY what we're seeing from the left today.

It's why every time I respond to people like you, they post openly and I'm forced to use a throwaway. It's reverse McCarthyism. You probably think that's progress too, but you didn't convert me or anybody else, you just made us go into hiding. But we can still vote while we're hiding.

I didn't vote for Trump, but I will vote for a thousand Trumps before I give up freedom of speech in America. If we don't have that in America then it's all for nothing. As long I keep reading this garbage from people on the left, I'll happily be a single-issue voter.

Re:First Amendment in Peril? by chrisco255 on Saturday August 19, 2017 @06:24PM (#15055971)
Unless they are literally calling for imminent violence against other human beings, it is their right to protest. It's your right to counter-protest all the same. But it's not your right to get violent. Ever. Only in self-defense. What the hell happened to "sticks and stones may break my bones, but words will never hurt me"?
Re:First Amendment in Peril? by alkonaut on Sunday August 20, 2017 @07:02AM (#15057912)
I never said it was counterprotester's "right" to intervene physically. I do argue it's in rare cases the right "right" to do.

My point is that if left unrestricted, free speech kills itself. Those who speak against it can end it without ever doing anything violent.

You can't wait for something illegal to intervene.

I'm not saying it's somehow "wrong" to have a 1st amendment style law as in the US - I'm saying it doesn't matter. When people speak against the open society and people's equal value, society will try to stop them. If it's in the law as in Germany then those that intervene have police uniform. When it's not law, those who intervene don't have police uniforms, and do formal "right" to do it.

Third option where nazis speak freely and people listen and then meet their opinions with their own? Not happening, anywhere.

Re:First Amendment in Peril? by Broken_Hippo on Saturday August 19, 2017 @07:01AM (#15052734)
How far has that gotten? Seriously.

Trying to compromise with a nazi is like agreeing to putting a kitten in the blender at half speed instead of full speed. These aren't folks that reason and persuasion is working for, as they think they are reasonable.

Re:First Amendment in Peril? by throwaway0255 on Saturday August 19, 2017 @01:36PM (#15054562)
Have you considered the fact that most of our great-grandparents who defeated the nazis also hold positions on foreign policy and social issues that would likely cause them to fall under your definition of "nazi"?
Re:First Amendment in Peril? by dTal on Saturday August 19, 2017 @04:04PM (#15055288)
The "Nazis" in the Charlotteville incident were literally waving Nazi flags, throwing Hitler salutes, and shouting "Heil Trump". I don't think your definition needs to be overbroad to include that.
Re:First Amendment in Peril? by Broken_Hippo on Sunday August 20, 2017 @05:06AM (#15057604)
So? You do realize that WWII was quite some time ago and society has changed since then. We also had African-Americans fighting, who went back to a segregated society. Women weren't their own person - heck, in the 70's women generally couldn't get a credit card without male approval. Oddly enough, the US also turned away Jewish refugees before we got involved in the war. I think these things were as wrong then as they are now, we've just updated the laws and society to show this. So yes, of course some of the views from the 40's are going to be evil, crass views today. And yes, if someone hasn't updated their social views from the 40's or 50's, I'm gonna keep my distance. It isn't like we'd ever get along anyway - I'm a boyish bisexual woman, an immigrant (In norway, from the US), someone that dates outside of her "race" and can easily be called a "sand nigger" if I have too much of a tan.

But overall, they were fighting a greater evil compared to the times. It doesn't matter if their views are now considered outdated, they were doing the right thing for the time.

Re:First Amendment in Peril? by valuearb on Saturday August 19, 2017 @02:04PM (#15054707)
How far do you need to go? Mind control until everyone thinks exactly as you do?

You can't change peoples minds by restricting their speech. Those people will always exist, some will change over time. In the mean time let them out themselves.

Re:First Amendment in Peril? by Toboe on Saturday August 19, 2017 @10:21AM (#15053502)
>My whole life, liberals were so proud to declare that they defend their opposition's right to speech even though they don't agree with it. When did this change?

Most likely at some point the perception went from the danger being 'offense' or maybe delays in bettering society ("if we keep explaining how gay marriage hurts nobody and helps parts of society, people will eventually come around, just gotta keep arguing!") to the danger being literally people dying ("They killed 1 counter protester, injured 19 and marched past a synagogue, hurling anti-semitic slurs... What are they going to do next?")

Re:First Amendment in Peril? by alkonaut on Saturday August 19, 2017 @07:09AM (#15052754)
> Or it could, you know, not be met with force outside the law, because we live in a civil society where people are free to think independently and express themselves, and we have laws against assaulting people.

This is of course the ideal, and works in most situations. That doesn't work though. You can't reason with intolerance.

This is the age old paradox of tolerance: how can you be tolerant and not tolerate intolerance?

The answer is you cannot and must not. You must resist intolerance and those that seek to end the open society

Violence must as always be a last resort of course.

Re:First Amendment in Peril? by hartator on Saturday August 19, 2017 @07:15AM (#15052768)
Violence is never a resort in a discussion.
Re:First Amendment in Peril? by alkonaut on Saturday August 19, 2017 @08:05AM (#15052932)
Discussion is rarely an alternative against intolerance either. That's the paradox of intolerance.

(https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance)

The notion that all speech is protected and all opinions can be listened to and met with other opinions is cute but unfortunately naive. I prefer non violent protest of course, but these are often violent people and if you deny them their platform there will undoubtedly be violence. It's an acceptable side effect, not a goal in itself.

Re:First Amendment in Peril? by aaronblohowiak on Saturday August 19, 2017 @01:59PM (#15054676)
As noted in the link you posted, the "paradox of tolerance" is controversial and not a fact. intolerance of intolerance is unjust.
Re:First Amendment in Peril? by alkonaut on Saturday August 19, 2017 @05:20PM (#15055686)
Of course it's not a fact, it's a philosophical idea (originally by Popper?). And of course it's controversial, especially in the US where 100% freedom of speech is protected by the constitution. But it's not that far fetched to think that the options are nearly free speech forever, versus completely free speech for a while.

It does hinge on the premise that speech is such a powerful tool that it can be used to remove fundamental freedoms. That's also just a hypothesis.