Re:Security Keys
by jimktrains2 on Friday August 18, 2017 @07:05PM
(#15050440)
No, you answered my question. I accepted that any/most/all authentication breaks down in some way of you can't trust tls certs or the browser/user agent.
Your original description is a bit ambiguous: were you referring to a case where the actual domain was being successfully man-in-the-middle'd with a valid TLS certificate? That's not something U2F aims to solve (and not something that people generally refer to as phishing).
Edit: Small correction: U2F makes use of TLS ChannelIDs, which, if I understand correctly, would help in that scenario (MitM with a trusted-but-attacker-controlled certificate on the "real" origin). I'm not sure if anyone other than Google makes use of this yet, as it requires a new TLS extension on the server.