News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On Norbert Blum’s claimed proof that P does not equal NP by naturalgradient on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @04:48PM (#15031251)
As a researcher, I think he is dismissive of Blum's work.

Let's take a moment to change perspective:

Imagine you worked for years on something and finally uploaded it on ArXiv, waiting for the community to weigh in. The following characters appear:

1. Someone known in the field does not bother reading it but says you are probably wrong, bets money on you being wrong and says he does not want to be bothered with it. How would you feel?

2. Someone else known in the community starts collating information/comments to help verify the proof or find instructive mistakes.

3. Another mathematician also believes Blum is wrong just because it is statistically likely, and does not want to spend time on something that will most likely lead nowhere. She keeps this opinion to herself and simply does not engage with the material. If approached, she declines to comment because she says he did not have time to check the proof.

Aaronson went for option 1 and in my highly personal opinion, it's the worst of the ones listed. It's standing at the sidelines being snarky. Just because he may as well be right does not make this behaviour any better.

It is the equivalent of laughing in an undergrad lecture when someone asks a naive question.

Re:On Norbert Blum’s claimed proof that P does not equal NP by Analemma_ on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @05:20PM (#15031472)
I think we're talking past each other and don't actually disagree. To clarify my last post: I don't approve of what Aaronson did. I think it was a dumb thing to say and (assuming my hypothesis is correct that he did it out of frustration at constantly being pestered to comment on CS news) he instead should've cooled off and, as you say, taken option 3. I think he was aiming his statements at his fans, not academia, and in his frustration forgot that there's no such thing anymore as a message only directed at one group.

I just want the problem with his behavior to be accurately diagnosed, because I think (again, I could be wrong) the solution is "better manage your temper with your non-academia fans" and not "rethink your relationship with other academics".

Re:On Norbert Blum’s claimed proof that P does not equal NP by naturalgradient on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @05:35PM (#15031579)
Thank you for clarifying this
Re:On Norbert Blum’s claimed proof that P does not equal NP by santaclaus on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @05:38PM (#15031598)
> Someone known in the field does not bother reading it but says you are probably wrong

Sounds like most academic paper reviews!

Re:On Norbert Blum’s claimed proof that P does not equal NP by EpicEng on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @05:15PM (#15031438)
But he didn't just come out and say it; he was responding to numerous people who were asking him about it.
Re:On Norbert Blum’s claimed proof that P does not equal NP by andrewflnr on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @05:14PM (#15031432)
Aaronson would far rather take option 3. The only reason he doesn't is that his fans won't let him.
Re:On Norbert Blum’s claimed proof that P does not equal NP by lgas on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @10:23PM (#15033270)
He could take option 3 regardless of what his fans "won't let him" do.