News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Token Effect by TheDong on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @04:21PM (#15031024)
It is resilient to tampering as far as you trust gpg.

It achieves this because cryptographic signatures exist fine without blockchains

Re:The Token Effect by discombobulate on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @04:39PM (#15031182)
You don't see any other issues? Ppl being centralised, servers (ETH has ~24k nodes), nothing like that?
Re:The Token Effect by TheDong on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @05:32PM (#15031560)
The gpg web of trust might be a better example, but it's a moot point either way.

The claim I'm refuting is that digital identity was impossible before the blockchain (Edit: or more difficult, either way, point stands). Digital identity is a cryptographic thing and a distributed thing. That doesn't mean it needs a blockchain.

People have been proving digital ownership and identities for longer than the blockchain, and the blockchain brings nothing new or interesting to the table in terms of identity.

Re:The Token Effect by discombobulate on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @05:58PM (#15031734)
I just reread the root comment:

> Are there any concrete uses of a blockchain that have clear advantages than to using a standard database other than cryptocurrencies?

Seems you're refuting something no one said, as far as I can tell.

Edit:

> Digital identity is a cryptographic thing and a distributed thing

How is it distributed? I assumed it was some company's servers -- maybe in multiple data centres around the world. But nothing like 24k nodes (& possibly more in the future).

---

Edit (reply to your edit):

I think the claim is that the identity system will be more resilient, not that it will be easier to implement. Censorship resistance.

I'd imagine it'll be harder to implement & cost more. A trade-off.

Which is along the lines of what I originally asked,

> Is Keybase resilient against the country's government in which it resides?

You said that gpg was. But didn't mention the computers. I asked about the servers & the ppl. (We didn't talk about the team).

The need wasn't specified. I'm presuming it's censorship resistance. Governments can't meddle with identities. Wipe someone off the face of the earth.