You're absolutely right. I was stretching a bit with that one, and looking back, I'm not really sure that I should have included it, because I have many of the same sentiments that you do.

That said, I have seen similar Ask YC posts that do cover the exact same ground as old ones and annoy me a bit more than that one. I guess I was trying to use that one as an example of such a submission, although it wasn't really a good example.