I don't even really know who is right about a Python GIL. When working with C, I have a strong preference for separate processes and mmaps. When working with Perl (which I use a lot more than Python), I've never really felt much urge to use threading. Aesthetically, although I haven't really used it, I think Erlang's message passing approach is much better than native threads. But maybe Gustavo's right --- better threading would indeed allow lots of cool things to be done.
That aside, what saddens me about the exchange between Gustavo and Brett is the misconnect. It strikes me as obvious that the key for Gustavo here is to show that it's in Brett's self-interest to improve threading in Python. I didn't see any attempt of this. Instead, he seems to be taking exactly the tack Brett just finished saying was ruinous to his morale.
So having people say "this sucks you guys should fix it" 100x a day, with increasing levels of "you owe me" or "you suck" tone in their voices is depressing and frustrating.
Especially when you've been at it awhile. Guido must have skin like a bloody rhinoceros.
It's really not that hard. You don't even have to use C, you can do it in Python. Can you write a brainfuck interpreter? Congratulations, you now have a virtual machine with eight bytecodes. Build from there.
Kein-Hong Man's "No-Frills Guide" to the Lua VM documents one set of reasonably general bytecodes. (http://luaforge.net/docman/view.php/83/98/ANoFrillsIntroToLu...) There's a good section on virtual machines in the last chapter of _The Practice of Programming_, too.
Keeping reverse compatibility is a huge pain, though. No argument there!
* From Abdulaziz Ghuloum's excellent "An Incremental Approach to Compiler Construction" (http://scheme2006.cs.uchicago.edu/11-ghuloum.pdf).
Don't be so sure, there are a lot of research in this area and it is not black magic.
you're still pretty early in the project's lifecycle. software projects generally move fastest and have the least difficult challenges early on, as a general rule, in my experience. once you have a lot of users, and legacy dependencies, and have to work right on N platforms, and handle edge cases, and be performant, and the codebase becomes so big you no longer remember all the details, and maybe a few years have passed since you were working on it full-time, etc., then you'll find that velocity and agility decreases.
I've never written a VM, and I don't think I'd be very good at it. I've written useful modules other people use, spoken at a Python conference, and have other OSS code in various places. I'm not a succubus, at least I hope I'm not. I don't even mind multithreading in Python, since I use Threads and Queues and they work just fine for my purposes. But I'm sure, other more cooler things would happen if CPython had the same kind of multithreaded coolness that Jython and IronPython have. I don't think it makes me a bad person if I say that.