Re:We Fight for the Users
by dingo_bat on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @08:03AM
(#15017376)
It's not irrelevant. What Google and go daddy did is tantamount to censorship. And that actually does prevent somebody from exercising free speech.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:We Fight for the Users
by sixstringtheory on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @09:23AM
(#15017947)
Private corporations and government are different, legally and philosophically. You won't be able to apply a law written specifically restricting the government to private citizens or corporations without a constitutional amendment.
What Google and GoDaddy did was the private citizen equivalent of hearing someone else state their opinion, allowing the words to enter their brain, think about them, and then decide they do not espouse those opinions, so they will not go around stating them to other people as fact. That is not censorship, it's just good sense.
Whether or not Google and Godaddy's actions are appropriate is a separate discussion from whether or not the government can compel political websites to disclose their visitor logs.
Re:We Fight for the Users
by dragonwriter on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @01:52PM
(#15020578)
> What Google and go daddy did is tantamount to censorship
It is censorship (not “tantamount”), but censorship of the sort (private actors deciding on what views to promote with their own resources) that the idea of “free speech” in general, and the First Amendment in particular, exist to protect.
Re:We Fight for the Users
by walterstucco on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @11:38AM
(#15019210)
They did what they thought it's best for their platforms
It's theirs, Google and Godaddy are not public libraries.
I can't stop you from screaming pro Nazi propaganda on the streets
But if you do it in my home, I kick you out.
Simple as that