News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by wolco on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @01:16AM (#15015697)
And they do control access.

When you type in a url a request is made and the server responds. Linkedin controls that response and can send back whatever it likes.

McDonalds can control who they sell a burger to but if I want to give my burger to a homeless man outside they shouldn't be allowed to stop me. In this case it's worse the place will tell me the price of a burger but won't allow me to tell the anyone else.

Once the information is public it has entered the public domain

Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by icebraining on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @07:36AM (#15017217)
Linkedin controls that response and can send back whatever it likes.

That's exactly what this injunction prohitibts them from doing: "To the extent LinkedIn has already put in place technology to prevent hiQ from accessing these public profiles, it is ordered to remove any such barriers"

Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by shakna on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @12:39PM (#15019782)
Which is why this is an anti-trust case.

LinkedIn have freely provided public data to any competitor but hiQ. If they were preventing any company from taking the data, say by putting it behind a user login with licensing, it would likely not be under consideration.