Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public...
by rootlocus on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @07:03AM
(#15017067)
> But when all is said and done, I don't believe in copyrighting a number. I don't believe that it is anyone's right to dictate how bits that enter devices I own are used.
Numbers can and are used to represent anything and everything. This has implications far beyond DRM. For instance: I don't believe you have the right to use my photo to make a defamatory Facebook account in my name.
Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public...
by dheera on Thursday August 17, 2017 @01:35PM
(#15038921)
In this case, I say the crimes are:
- defaming
- claiming that I am you
and not in copying numbers.
Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public...
by rootlocus on Friday August 18, 2017 @11:21AM
(#15046968)
If you stick a knife in someone's chest the crime is murder not wielding a knife.
To paraphrase:
> I don't believe that it is anyone's right to dictate how the knives I own are used.
And yet the law still dictates you keep your knives away from my chest. Point being: your freedom of using your bits is dictated by the same laws that dictate your freedom of using knives.
As of now deep down in my heart I don't really believe in intellectual property. I do believe in respect, and in giving credit where credit is due.
But when all is said and done, I don't believe in copyrighting a number. I don't believe that it is anyone's right to dictate how bits that enter devices I own are used.
How do protect inventions and businesses, you ask? I say:
* If you have a secret you don't want to be distributed, don't share it with anyone you cannot trust. Trained models are a good example.
* Provide a service that only provides a limited amount of information per unit time. The user is free to use the information they obtained however they wish, but even a thousand users wouldn't have a way to copy your whole database in a reasonable amount of time. Google search, for example.
* Alternatively, if you are not sure you trust someone, take collateral from them. (e.g. "It is legal to share this information about me, but then it is also legal for me to share this other information about you [that you probably don't want shared]", or "If you share this information about me, you will be kicked out from the company/platform/etc.", or an Ethereum smart contract that causes you to be fined if someone else demonstrates that they got a piece of information that I shared with you.)
* Build businesses that have stronger value propositions than restricting how information is used. Network effects, physical hardware, good service and support, good use of massive amounts of back-end data that only you have, are all options.