Because the justice department is demanding the IP address of everybody who ever connected to that website
It's the epitome of silencing exactly that speech, which is protected by the first amendment.
https://www.popehat.com/2017/08/14/department-of-justice-use...
"DreamHost's brief illuminates the key issues: the search warrant is dangerously overbroad, and implicates protected speech. The Department of Justice isn't just seeking communications by the defendants in its case. It's seeking the records of every single contact with the site — the IP address and other details of every American opposed enough to Trump to visit the site and explore political activism. It seeks the communications with and through the site of everyone who visited and commented, whether or not that communication is part of a crime or just political expression about the President of the United States. The government has made no effort whatsoever to limit the warrant to actual evidence of any particular crime. If you visited the site, if you left a message, they want to know who and where you are — whether or not you did anything but watch TV on inauguration day. This is chilling, particularly when it comes from an administration that has expressed so much overt hostility to protesters, so relentlessly conflated all protesters with those who break the law, and so deliberately framed America as being at war with the administration's domestic enemies."
Demanding IP == silencing speech?
Yes, absolutely!You may think twice in comenting in a public discourse if you must fear to wind up in some enemy of the state database.
It's like the cops asking for your Id if they find that you were attending a fascist rally where a girl was killed for being openly anti-fascist
Nothing to worry here about free speech
Edit: just realized that this comment may have already wound up in an NSA server somewhere lol.
It's a website that specifically attacks the president.
So what? As long there is no true threat that's their first amendment right to do.But moreover: What does that have to do with visitors to the site who don't even comment, but just visit the site?
Here's some insight on the subject if you want to educate yourself :
https://www.popehat.com/2013/06/24/whats-the-line-between-il...
Who, precisely? Literally anyone who visited the website? You're projecting criminality where none exists.
Note: I'd not post threats. I try to avoid doing stupid things.
There's a false equivalence in your example. HN is not a website created to commit acts of treason. Consider a more apt example (but more extreme): there is a website created by ISIS. Many people visit it. A few post threats against America or its president. Is it unethical to pull data about every visitor? The whole website's purpose is terrorism. I'd want the FBI to get every IP address and ascertain the risk that each visitor poses. I'd feel safe that way.
What you're saying applies to sites like Google, Facebook, HN, Twitter etc.
I'm not a Muslim, I'm a secular Buddhist. I just wanted to understand what they were fighting about.
Additionally, no! The site in question's primary purpose is not illegal. That a subset of users have made threats in no way implicates the whole. It's not a 'make threats about Trump' site.
Also, I'm not actually sure you know what treason is. Treason is actually pretty clearly defined. This isn't it. Even if someone assassinated the president, that's not treason.
So, yes, it is unethical - and almost certainly a violation of the 4th. I'm not okay with ceding the protections of the constitution to assuage your fear. Terrorists scare me exactly none, nor do these people threatening the president scare me.
If they were gonna assassinate the president, they'd not announce it online. If they do, they are too stupid to act on the threat. By all means, prosecute them. However, narrow the warrant to just the accounts that made threats.
Fear doesn't motivate me to give up my rights. It also doesn't motivate me to insist you give up your rights.
Then the DOJ/FBI/CIA will investigate you and find you harmless and innocent. No worries. I'd still want them to check, though, if you were my neighbor (nothing personal here, just hypothetically saying).
> Additionally, no! The site in question's primary purpose is not illegal... It's not a 'make threats about Trump' site.
I think it is. Maybe it is subjective. I'll let the DOJ and the courts decide. What do you think?
> That a subset of users have made threats in no way implicates the whole.
True, and I never said that. I just want them to be investigated, or even just ruled out.
> So, yes, it is unethical - and almost certainly a violation of the 4th. I'm not okay with ceding the protections of the constitution to assuage your fear. Terrorists scare me exactly none, nor do these people threatening the president scare me.
I don't think it is unethical. I think it is unethical to provide a platform to violent terrorists, and defend them. I'm glad you're fearless, but I want a society in which these violent anti-democracy lunatics rot inside a jail, and not roam the streets.
> If they were gonna assassinate the president, they'd not announce it online. If they do, they are too stupid to act on the threat. By all means, prosecute them. However, narrow the warrant to just the accounts that made threats.
DOJ thinks all accounts are suspect. They would like to check. I think it is perfectly reasonable, given the level of violence we have seen from these groups recently.
> Fear doesn't motivate me to give up my rights. It also doesn't motivate me to insist you give up your rights.
Amen, but let's let the police do their job. They create an environment which allows us to be free, and to say anything we want without fear of repercussions.
Do you know what a search warrant is, why it is needed, and what it entails?
I'm going to assume you don't.
It is a writ to search a specific place for specific evidence. Note: you can be prosecuted for incidental discoveries over the course of a lawful search.
It is needed because it is a right. The government has limited rights. They can only search when there is probable cause. Probable cause is when a reasonable person would judge there to be a high probability of discovering evidence in the search.
It entails a very specific process in which a judge decides the scope of the warrant. As mentioned above, it is for specific evidence and areas. In this case, those would be the IP addresses of those making threats.
That's pretty much it. This warrant is going to be found to be overly broad and not pass muster. That's a good thing.
I realize you're scared. That's okay. What's not okay is asking/demanding others cede their rights to make you feel less scared. There are no terrorists that are going to try to harm you. Of all those people on the site, only a few have violated the law.
I can't take away your rights because I am scared. I'm glad and I wouldn't do it if I could. We only take rights away when there's an articulated, and reasonable, suspicion of unlawful activity.
Go ahead, get the account information for those who made threats. The next judge is going to rule the warrant overly broad, anyhow. Good on the hosting company, though sad that this has become almost routine.
About three months ago, on a different site, I had a conversation with a very liberal lady. The conversation was about someone being detained for failing to unlock their encrypted drive when demanded to do so by the judge.
The thing is, she wanted him to be held in perpetuity, because she was certain he was a pedophile. No, she was certain - and repeated this, over and over again.
Granted, the guy is probably a pedophile.
However, no evidence suggests he is. He just refuses to unlock his drive for the investigation. She wants him to be detained until he has proven himself innocent. She further insisted that all allegations should result in the accused needing to prove their innocence.
You know... I served as a Marine. That's how I paid for college. Sometimes, I'm pretty frustrated too. This sort of thinking, on all ends of the spectrum, isn't going to help us have a functional justice system, a system that is needed for a democracy.
And, yes, I am on the political left. I just call it as I see it. No, I don't have a solution. I don't have the answers. Damned right, it's frustrating.
Dreamhost wasn't created to commit acts of treason either.
>Is it unethical to pull data about every visitor? The whole website's purpose is terrorism. I'd want the FBI to get every IP address and ascertain the risk that each visitor poses.
You don't understand how websites or IP addresses work. Any moron can visit a site, and IP addresses mean literally nothing. Give me your IP, and I'll prove that by spoofing it and getting the secret service showing up on your front porch.
>I'd feel safe that way.
I wouldn't. I would rather have a terrorist attack daily than live in a totalitarian regime.
>What you're saying applies to sites like Google, Facebook, HN, Twitter etc.
Pot? This is kettle. You're black.
Thousands of sites were created and used from 2009-2017 to plan, organize and conduct protests against the President, were you as concerned then about such sites?