News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by mrkgnao on Monday August 14, 2017 @11:53PM (#15015299)
Making HTTP requests is the same thing as having rays of light reflect off the storefront, I'd say.
Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by dawidloubser on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @04:50AM (#15016502)
Actually, it's not. In your analogy, the storefront is completely passive and unaffected.

What is actually happening, is that somebody is walking into the store, asks a question about the stock or the price of the products on sale, which the store employee willingly answers.

Then, all of the sudden, the store wishes to control what you do with the answer that was willingly given to you.

This is clearly absurd - and so too is wanting to control what people do with publically-available HTTP data. If it's public, it's public.

I personally do feel that LinkedIn is within their full rights to attempt to detect and restrict content being served to screen-scraping agents, but they must then accept that screen-scraping agents must be allowed to use any means necessary to impersonate a "normal" user browsing the (public) information that they publish.

This can't be a one-sided freedom.

Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by rayiner on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @07:38AM (#15017229)
No that's not what's happening. What was happening is that the store clerk was noticing that an employee from a competitor was coming in and asking questions about the price, and then refused to answer the questions. The judge ordered LinkedIn to respond to the competitors HTTP requests.
Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by kevin_thibedeau on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @10:03AM (#15018235)
Where do you draw the line between this and a DoS flood of HTTP requests? At some point a provider has to be able to rate limit requests to maintain service for legitimate users.
Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by rayiner on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @10:47AM (#15018655)
I don't. I think owners of web servers should be able to selectively choose to respond to requests however they please (so long as they don't violate any e.g. civil rights laws).