The problem is that a 'true riot' could easily be the spark that provides the activation energy for a 'true civil war'.
Most of these things are about activation levels being crossed and then there is really almost no way back.
This seems unlikely.
This reaction of seeking the individuals out who took part, in whatever small way, is a direct response to that. It makes people feel good that they can serve a common good by seeking the individuals out online, but of course there are going to be people incorrectly identified.
In fact, one of the things commonly stated about the rise of the National Socialists in Germany, is that not enough people stood up to stop it. This is tacit approval for some form of vigilantism. So what do people do? Wait for the authorities who are failing to act? Or act themselves? It's a hard decision. On the one hand it will cause escalation of the fight as both sides react in this way, on the other it's important that we as a society don't allow fridge elements to destroy our fundamental values.
That's a good point, but then you have to be extra careful not to blackball the wrong people. Going about this half assed is a bigger problem than doing nothing at all.