News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Fight for the Users by nv-vn on Monday August 14, 2017 @09:06PM (#15014509)
>They can speak their minds about anything they'd like, so long as they don't advocate for the suppression of the rights of others.

And one would posit that you could speak your mind about anything you'd like, so long as you don't advocate for suppressing their rights. From their perspective, what they are doing isn't even suppressing anyone's rights -- in their eyes, their God has mandated that doing so is _not_ a right. Everything is a matter of viewpoint, and in an alternate reality someone would be advocating for you to be silenced on the same basis.

Re:We Fight for the Users by rpearl on Monday August 14, 2017 @11:20PM (#15015123)
Eh, fuck it.

What's your solution?

I gave a nice, uniform principle that allows as much as tolerance as is possible without eroding all of it. Many before me have offered it too. Again, it's not a new idea.

You pick it apart, claiming that in some (specifically intolerant of others) religious person's point of view, their magical god favoritism allows them to stigmatize people, so therefore my principle just doesn't work.

You're right: my principle excludes people. It excludes the intolerant, where intolerance is identified by the simple test I outlined. And that's it. That is all it excludes. It excludes people for their choices to harm others. But your hypothetical (again, specifically intolerant) person's magical god-favoritism instead excludes people for who they are. That's the difference.

So, we as a society can choose one of these ways or the other. And I argue we continue to treat tolerance as a social contract for the simple reason that the other option, free speech absolutism ...breaks. It erodes down to an intolerant society, where a violent few pry away the rights of everyone else. But if you treat tolerance as a social contract, the result is stable.

Re:We Fight for the Users by KGIII on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @05:13AM (#15016601)
If I may?

I hold a bit of a strong view, here. Criminalize actions. In all but the rarest if cases, speech should be protected.

If somebody tells you to go punch a Nazi, they shouldn't get in trouble. You should, if you go punch a Nazi. Not that I like Nazis, but that you shouldn't assault them when they aren't being violent or an immediate threat to your physical safety.

I only think speech should be punished when you can show demonstrable harm. Libel, slander, credible threats, and things like that. Some idiot yelling about gassing Jews isn't a credible threat, even if reprehensible. However, if they happen to have a gas chamber, and amassed a bunch of Jews, that's a credible threat - though I am going to guess their speech is the least of our concerns, if they got that far.

I don't want speech to be illegal, in all but the rarest of circumstances.

Re:We Fight for the Users by gravy on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @02:03PM (#15020707)
Free speech doesn't apply to any of those examples because there was an action outside of "speech" or "thought". Speech, thought, etc. should never be illegal.
Re:We Fight for the Users by KGIII on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @02:46PM (#15021124)
I'm not sure you followed the thread? Hit parent a few times.