News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by dahart on Monday August 14, 2017 @08:01PM (#15014177)
> If you're offering a service that is public

LinkedIn is not a public service, LinkedIn is a private, for-profit business. A public service is normally publicly funded. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_service

> with the intent to your users that such information will be available publicly, you cannot then police what users of that data you consider to be "public" because it serves your business interest.

LinkedIn licenses their service to both free and paid users, and they can legally and do attempt to police what users can access the information. Whether it's enforceable or not, LinkedIn has a EULA and use of their service, whether you have an account or not, is presumably governed by their license.

They are well within their right to restrict requests being made by spammers and DDOS attacks, for example. How do you tell between legitimate requests and abusive ones, and how could you compel public access without enabling abusive ones?

> LinkedIn, of course, wants to get all the benefit of the public Internet with providing as little as they can.

The internet isn't a public service yet either, at least in the US. I think it should be, but it currently is not. This is conflating the knowledge that everyone with a computer and net access can currently access a LinkedIn server with the idea that everyone must be able to.

Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by smilekzs on Monday August 14, 2017 @08:06PM (#15014205)
> > If you're offering a service that is public

> LinkedIn is not a public service

A service that is public(ly accessible through Internet) != Public Service.

Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by dahart on Monday August 14, 2017 @08:09PM (#15014234)
That is correct. It's unfortunate, but such is the difficulty of language. "Public service" is a term that has precedence and legal meaning in the US, feel free to check out the article that I linked.

It's totally fine to call a service that is publicly accessible a public service, but it is going to lead to miscommunication if you are suggesting that this public service should have the same kind of legal requirements and regulations that the other kind of "Public Service" already has.

Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by vacri on Monday August 14, 2017 @09:06PM (#15014510)
The GP did not call it a "Public service", but a service that was public, and the further context around the comment made it abundantly clear they were talking about access, not government provision.

The very first thing you did in quoting the GP was rearrange those words to suit your hobby-horse; a classic straw-man.

Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by dahart on Monday August 14, 2017 @10:12PM (#15014786)
I don't understand what you mean.

The GP said "you cannot then police what users of that data you consider to be 'public' because it serves your business interest."

Yes, they can.

That sentence is explicitly describing the public expectations of a public service in the government sense. LinkedIn can police whatever they want because of their business interest, precisely because they are a private entity and not a public service in the government provision sense. Despite their offering information to unregistered site visitors, they are within their rights to refuse service to anyone at any time for any reason.

I did not rearrange GP's quote, and GP seemed to be conflating public access with government provision, which is why I brought up the distinction.

Are you saying that you agree with GP that LinkedIn should be compelled by law to provide public access to all?

Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by pm24601 on Monday August 14, 2017 @10:29PM (#15014856)
> Yes, they can

The judge just said .. no they can't. Until the judge's ruling is overturned. Your statement is incorrect.

And you keep using the phrase "public service" which is not the issue at hand.

A store owner can not dictate who is allowed to read or take pictures of their store window. Effectively the judge was saying that if LinkedIn offers information that does not require a login - LinkedIn can not then tell someone that they can't use the info that is publicly visible.

No mention of "public service" - please stop conflating the two concepts.

Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by dahart on Monday August 14, 2017 @10:50PM (#15014962)
> The judge just said .. no they can't. Until the judge's ruling is overturned.

This was an injunction, no ruling has been made.

> Effectively the judge was saying that ...

This is an injunction in LinkedIn vs HiQ, the judge did not share an opinion about site visitors who aren't logged in, nor make any ruling about whether publicly visible data can be restricted or not.

> A store owner can not dictate who is allowed to read or take pictures of their store window.

True, from outside the store. But to make a more complete analogy to this case, a store owner can dictate what you can read or photograph while inside the store. And the store owner can legally block the view to the outside anytime she wants.

> "public service" which is not the issue at hand.

I just explained above, and maybe you reacted quickly without understanding what I wrote. I'm not sure why I'm getting heavy pushback on this, it is both accurate and not controversial.

I reacted to @iamleppert's idea that LinkedIn can't police it's users. The fact is that they can police their users (except for HiQ until the case is over). My interpretation is that he was saying they shouldn't be allowed to police this "public" data. Do you think I misunderstood? I'm not conflating the concepts, I am distinguishing between them. It may be that one is a red herring or that I misunderstood, but on 2nd and 3rd reading it still looks to me like GP is suggesting that LinkedIn should not be allowed to restrict access to some users. If that were true it would turn LinkedIn into a public service, hence the reason why I'm talking about public services.

Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by wolco on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @01:43AM (#15015818)
If the store owner tells you information you can write it down and share it. They can refuse to answer questions but they cannot take back any public data they made available.

They have a right to ignore your question and put rules around who they will respond to and when.

When they respond with data that cannot be copywritten (a name, address, title of past position,etc) of course someone can reuse those pieces.

Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by icebraining on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @07:43AM (#15017254)
They can refuse to answer questions

Which is what LinkedIn did, and what HiQ is suing them over.

Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by smokeyj on Monday August 14, 2017 @08:24PM (#15014307)
> LinkedIn is not a public service

Boo. OP said it's a service offered to the public. Don't need to move the goal post.

> Whether it's enforceable or not, LinkedIn has a EULA and use of their service, whether you have an account or not, is presumably governed by their license.

Turns out I also have a EULA. And when linkedin responds to my HTTP requests, they opt into my EULA agreement.

It sounds like LinkedIn doesn't want to be accessible from the world wide web. Going offline is always an option.

Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by dahart on Monday August 14, 2017 @08:32PM (#15014346)
> Boo. OP said it's a service offered to the public. Don't need to move the goal post.

Nothing moved. OP also said, in the same sentence, "you cannot then police what users of that data you consider to be 'public' because it serves your business interest." Yes, they can. It is clear from context that OP was suggesting that LinkedIn should be held to the legal standards of a "Public Service" in the government entity sense of the term. This is not the case, LinkedIn has no legal requirement to provide anything to the public. Booing me doesn't change that.

> Turns out I also have a EULA. And when linkedin responds to my HTTP requests, they opt into my EULA agreement.

Good luck with that!

Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by smokeyj on Monday August 14, 2017 @08:37PM (#15014368)
Just like you can't fart in public and charge bystanders for the scent - you can't broadcast facts into the public and expect people not to recall them. I mean, you can. But good luck with that!
Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by DannyBee on Monday August 14, 2017 @11:19PM (#15015116)
"Just like you can't fart in public and charge bystanders for the scent - you can't broadcast facts into the public and expect people not to recall them. I mean, you can. But good luck with that! "

Do you also believe you can take the satellite tv signals beamed at your house and decrypt them? After all, they broadcasted them as widely as they possibly could! If they didn't want you to watch them, they shouldn't have sent it to you!

(This is a great in-theory argument that simply does not mesh well with our law in reality)

Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by wsy on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @11:07AM (#15018896)
If the broadcasted stream is encrypted, and the key is not public, it is obviously not public data.

If the stream is unencrypted, the reasoning applies perfectly.

Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by icebraining on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @07:44AM (#15017260)
Personally, I do think it should be legal to decrypt them.
Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by graphitezepp on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @09:28AM (#15017972)
Same. Little did parent commentator know, there are plenty of radical "all information should be free" thinkers in these parts.
Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by dahart on Monday August 14, 2017 @08:45PM (#15014414)
> you can't broadcast facts into the public and expect people not to recall them

That's a straw man, that is not the issue here. LinkedIn is not recalling the data, they asked to stop HiQ from scraping and collating their data and using it for their own business.

This is already in the EULA, so what HiQ is doing may already be breaking the law.

8.2 Don'ts You agree that you will not:

k. Develop, support or use software, devices, scripts, robots, or any other means or processes (including crawlers, browser plugins and add-ons, or any other technology or manual work) to scrape the Services or otherwise copy profiles and other data from the Services;

m. Copy, use, disclose or distribute any information obtained from the Services, whether directly or through third parties (such as search engines), without the consent of LinkedIn;

ae. Use bots or other automated methods to access the Services, add or download contacts, send or redirect messages;

Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by avip on Monday August 14, 2017 @08:55PM (#15014451)
(fun fact, not strictly important here) - 8.2.k was added quite recently [1], likely triggered by the HiQ case.

[1] https://blog.linkedin.com/2017/april/10/updates-to-our-terms...

[2] Here https://github.com/tosdr/tosback2/blob/master/crawl/linkedin... is an older version of the ToS, which one can read while enjoying the irony of a crawler focused on scrapping ToS

Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by smokeyj on Monday August 14, 2017 @09:03PM (#15014487)
> LinkedIn is not recalling the data, they asked to stop HiQ from scraping and collating their data and using it for their own business.

It's not LinkedIn's right to tell me how to use facts. Just like I can't make LinkedIn liable for my EULA. It doesn't constitute an actual legal agreement.

That said I think the judge is wrong that LI should remove barriers from accessing the information. Information is speech. To mandate information be suppressed or produced is less than ideal.

Re:U.S. judge says LinkedIn cannot block startup from public... by dahart on Monday August 14, 2017 @10:01PM (#15014746)
> It's not LinkedIn's right to tell me how to use facts.

Yes, you're right about that. But it is LinkedIn's right to tell you how to use their service. Lots of people ignore what they say, and they might not be able to sue someone who breaks their rules, but they can state the rules.

They said they don't want bots scraping their site, and that's their right. They wrote software to detect specific bots & IPs, and refuse service. That's also their right, in my opinion.

Sites who want to use LinkedIn's database are free to collect their own facts instead. I don't know if this is what you were suggesting, but LinkedIn's refusal to serve HiQ's bots is not suppressing any speech, in my view.

> That said I think the judge is wrong that LI should remove barriers from accessing the information.

We totally agree. What are we arguing about?