News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to determine a protein’s shape by drug_design_PhC on Monday August 14, 2017 @08:01PM (#15014175)
> Coevolution was part of it, but the actual "breakthrough" in their paper was the use metagenome sequences for protein structure prediction

Ah -- I hadn't read into the metagenomics aspect. That is quite substantial. Thanks for the link.

> I don't disagree that engineering talent is needed in this field, but in this case it's not really fair to boil it down to an engineering problem. I mean, this work relies on the development of the Rosetta energy function, which is a wild beast of a scientific problem

Interesting -- I guess my disagreement here stems from the definitions of "science" and "engineering". I agree that Rosetta scoring function development is extremely valuable. I also agree that figuring out how to efficiently balance coevolution-derived constraints vs. traditional Rosetta score is a substantial accomplishment. However, the profs on my committee consider this type of work (which I find really meaningful) to be more "engineering" (or "optimization") than "science". Their definitions had never sat well with me, and I'm glad you agree that this is valuable science.

There are no comments on this comment yet.