Excuse me while I enjoy the benefits of our fascist socialism.
And most Americans are opposed to shit like the Hobby Lobby crap, just like most Europeans are opposed to what Russia does.
Also, cut out the whataboutism. It's dishonest.
No, you shouldn't if they are based on hate
Countries that allow this kind of "political support" are idiotic.
The main difference between Europe and USA is that we Europeans have learned from our past mistakes
If money wasn't speech, the government would easily be able stifle speech simply by limiting what advertising and promotions a corporation could do. So the ruling and legal precept are prefectly valid.
Aside from that, "based on hate" is a completely meaningless phrase. It's great for creating stuff like "blasphemy laws" though, I suppose. In your opinion, should I not be able to insult Scientology? Is criticism "hate?" Are insults? What about making a negative documentary about Catholicism, or any other religion?
>The main difference between Europe and USA is that we Europeans have learned from our past mistakes
Are you sure? Europe doesn't seem too stable lately.
Political influence reform is a whole separate issue and I think the problems are structural and go much deeper than just "corporate money in politics."
Personally, I think the idea of a "representative" democracy is simply outdated and problematic. Representatives can be bought, and that will always be the case. I'd prefer to see more direct democracy (with constitutional constraints.) I believe you'll see society gradually transitioning towards that, as in California.
Of course you can
But then you have to suffer the consequences if what you said is against the law
For example if you say that scientology is a cult, it's your right to say so
If you say that members of scientology are pedophiles without any proof, it's not
When a right has no limits it's not a right anymore, it's a privilege
> What about making a negative documentary about Catholicism, or any other religion?
Seriously, if you don't get the difference between criticism and hate speech, I can't help you.
BTW, you can't say lightly anything bad about Scientology for the same reason Citizen United is a threat to freedom
They can throw an enormous amount of money to "the problem"
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientology_and_law#Cases_in_t...
http://www.nytimes.com/1997/03/09/us/scientology-s-puzzling-...
http://www.sptimes.com/News/32899/TampaBay/Hardball.html
> Are you sure? Europe doesn't seem too stable lately.
Still not killing each other in the streets over a stupid statue
You're obviously pro-free speech. But surely, if speech is so important, it is also important to make sure it can be effective. If one waters down definitions like that, the ability to speak effectively against dangers diminishes.
I'm an european, way too young to have seen WWII. But I deal with its broad consequences, that still permeate society and psyche in subtle ways, daily. To see the evil of fascism repurposed to mean something else, just makes me sad. Don't screw up our heritage please.
Then how, as an American, do you justify Ag_gag laws?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ag-gag
It seems to me that free speech values in the US are not quite as absolute as you make them out to be. Especially when the interest of powerful people or big corporations come to play.
I don't, and they have been repeatedly struck down by our courts. Checks and balances between overzealous legislators and our judicial branch.
Pointing at them is classic whataboutism. We have problems in the US. We mostly confront them headon rather than pretending they don't exist. Suppression of speech is pretending they don't exist.
Another example: Americans are constantly blasted by Europeans for racism. Racism is a very real problem in America - That's why groups like Black Lives Matter exist. We deal with these problems with speech, like the aforementioned group. As such, some fairly basic indicators, like the public opinion on miscegenation have been trending in a good direction - Less than 20% of America disapproves of it[1]. The data is not quite quantified in the same way, but there's an argument that in Germany, that number is more than 40%[2]. Across the EU, 35% of people would be upset if their child were dating a black person. The numbers are not directly comparable - The US numbers are about interracial marriage as a whole, not personalizing it about "your child", and I've seen firsthand that there's a difference. But those aren't numbers that swing that far. It might be equally bad, it might be a little worse in the US. It's not the sea change that it's so often presented as - Racism is a global problem, not a US one.
[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interracial_marriage_in_the_Un... [2]http://www.equineteurope.org/IMG/pdf/ebs_437_en.pdf
I don't think that my comment was whataboutism. Not when I reply to the following quote:
"As an American, I look down on the limits of speech in Europe with disdain"
Which implicitly puts an absolute to free speech in America. Which it's most definitely not.
I come from Italy, parents in Italy are upset even if you ask them what they think about their children marrying someone from the village 2 Kms away from theirs
But then they won't shoot anybody who does it
It's not really racism.
it's old people being old
Free speech isn't responsible for genocide; the electorate is.