News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Fight for the Users by dragonwriter on Monday August 14, 2017 @07:15PM (#15013898)
> Free speech is not just a constitutional amendment, it's a cultural value.

Its a phrase that different people use to express different culture values, but the one behind the Constitutional Amendment is, very clearly given the other evidence of the ideology of those wrote it, the freedom of private parties to speak and to use their own property to distribute their own speech and that of which they approve without constraint or compulsion by government.

It is not the idea that private parties, in general, are obligated, morally or otherwise, to amplify speech whether or not they agree with it, indeed, it is diametrically opposed to that idea.

It is true that there are some people who hold to the latter value and call it free speech, but that is entitlement rather than liberty.

Re:We Fight for the Users by sushisource on Monday August 14, 2017 @07:41PM (#15014044)
It's fairly easy to make parent comment's idea fit what you're saying. You just need one more level of indirection (like always!).

In this case, cloudflare or whatever, is exercising their free speech by saying "We care so much about free speech, we'll amplify these jerk's speech".

I agree that expecting someone to do this for you is indeed a privilege, not a right.

So I'd say the difference between your comments is more semantic than anything. Parent commentor doesn't really imply everyone has a right to this kind of amplification.