News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Fight for the Users by cortesoft on Monday August 14, 2017 @06:54PM (#15013759)
This is such a tricky issue. I do think so many of these sites do nothing but promote hate and violence. However, let's imagine we decide to go with the rule 'You are allowed to shut down a website that incites violence'

Someone has to determine what constitutes 'inciting violence'. There will be some websites that are targetted for shut down while some won't be; there is no way to get around this. What gets targetted will be the ones that go against the group who has the ability to choose the targets (a government agency or perhaps a private ISP).

Second, what stops a false flag from getting a site shutdown? If a site allows comments, a person hostile to the site could post a violent comment, and then you would have justification for shutting the site down.

Third, you will get false accusations. Take, for example, the civil rights movement in the sixties. You don't think state governments in the south wouldn't have accused the various protest groups as inciting violence? It doesn't matter that they were peaceful protests, they would have certainly argued that organizing sit ins and protest marches was a form of violence. While we might say, "Well clearly those were peacful and would be allowed to have their protest", that doesn't mean a court run by that same government wouldn't see differently. You don't think a southern court in the 60s would have sided with the government when they accused the civil rights groups of being violent?

Once you give the government an out to get around free speech requirements, they will take it whenever they can.

Re:We Fight for the Users by jquery on Monday August 14, 2017 @11:27PM (#15015161)
> Once you give the government an out to get around free speech requirements, they will take it whenever they can.

The current "out" is to let private companies run the entire infrastructure of speech itself. That's worrying.