News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by cgag on Monday August 14, 2017 @02:58PM (#15011509)
because we have to do this every time:

Either the principle is important and you support it or you don't. If you actually believe in freedom of speech you don't get to celebrate censorship by corporate entities because the constitution didn't forbid it.

Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by lightbyte on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:00PM (#15011543)
These are completely different concepts. Government != buisness. I can't choose to ignore the US government if I live here and don't like what they do. These people do not have to use Google if they do not agree with their decision.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by TheAdamAndChe on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:08PM (#15011650)
The issue here is that Google holds a monopoly on search, which has an incredible effect on the internet. Given that the gateway to the internet for most people is Google, should freedom of speech protections extend to it?
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by CydeWeys on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:15PM (#15011770)
We're not talking about Search though, we're talking about domain name registrar services. You're conflating separate issues.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by ggggtez on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:16PM (#15011782)
Considering there are more than one domain provider, your argument about search is irrelevant. Just because Google and GoDaddy kicked them out, doesn't mean there aren't dozens more companies who would take them in.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by gotrecruit on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:14PM (#15011757)
effect
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by TheAdamAndChe on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:35PM (#15012006)
Corrected, thank you
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by flunhat on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:07PM (#15011637)
What a terribly un-nuanced and simplistic view of freedom of speech. I do not support the government punishing anyone for the views they espouse. I do, however, support the right of private companies to regulate their private platforms, as long as they don't discriminate against protected classes laid out in law.

This all-or-nothing view has never been true, and that's kind of the point. Freedom of speech requires social dialogue and consequence to have value - the ability of private entities to reject what they don't like is what makes the whole thing work.

Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by tenaciousDaniel on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:08PM (#15011659)
As much as this conversation gets played out, I still find it really interesting. On one hand, there is a difference between free speech as a legal term, and the free speech principles that undergird it. You can argue that Google should abide by free speech principles in allowing open discourse, regardless of the legal requirement to do so. On the other hand, a fundamental component of free speech (expression in this case) principles is the right to free association. Google therefore should exercise its own judgement in selecting those with whom they do associate, and resist external demands to associate with someone they would rather not.

I believe that Google should feel free, both legally and socially, to act according to their conscience as a company. However, I believe that their conscience, as a massively powerful part of online communication, should be to remain neutral towards any legal communication that takes place on their platform. I think that's a more effective moral stance than the one they are taking.

Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by jtmarmon on Monday August 14, 2017 @02:59PM (#15011524)
i support corporations having the freedom to censor whoever they want on their own platforms
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by myrandomcomment on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:15PM (#15011771)
There is nothing wrong per say with your position. This becomes an issue when a corporation that is a delivery medium for information censors based on popular sentiment. If you are a domain register you are selling a resource that is publicly owned and therefor you should not be able to ban things you do not like. If you are a hosting provider of course you do not have to host that content but we need to be careful that the registers are not permitted to censor domains they do not like. The the right to register a domain is a government function we delegated to ICANN there for a domain is covered as "freedom of speech". Can you imagine the Internet if it was around in the 50s & 60s and the domains that would be banned because racism was okay?
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by dragonwriter on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:08PM (#15011658)
I believe that the right of private parties to be free from having speech compelled or repressed by the State is an important principal which means (except where it runs up against other important principals) permitting private censorship is important for the same reason as prohibiting public censorship.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by Clubber on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:11PM (#15011701)
Bingo. The people who are cheering this censorship will be damning it when it happens to them. You either fight for freedom of speech, or you live by the pleasure of the tyrant.

People cheering Google here, were you happy when Occupy Wall Street was run out of a public park, essentially censoring the movement? I certainly wasn't.

Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by CydeWeys on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:17PM (#15011792)
Occupy Wall Street isn't a relevant example to bring up because if it were a public park, then it would be referring to government censorship, whereas Google is private, so it's not relevant.

However, Zucotti Park is private, not public.

Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by Clubber on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:31PM (#15011964)
Censorship is still censorship, private censorship just isn't explicitly protected by the constitution.

Do we want to support a world where corporations can freely censor ideas they don't like? Is that a good world to live in?

Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by flunhat on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:49PM (#15012168)
Yes! That's the point of free speech - private entities can accept and reject ideas they like or dislike. The founders knew this, and they omitted any mention of private entities in the first amendment:

The text of the first amendment is: Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.

It says nothing about private entities regulating private platforms and that's on purpose - free speech means nothing without the private means to accept or reject it.

I feel that most of this confusion stems from people who live in different countries conflating their free speech laws with our own. In the United States, the government cannot regulate speech on the basis of its content, and this has always been the case. In the United States, private entities are free to regulate speech on private platforms, and this has also been the case since day 1 of the republic. This is nothing new for us Americans, and nothing particularly scary!

Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by Clubber on Monday August 14, 2017 @05:34PM (#15013165)
There is no confusion. I understand the constitution only protects free speech from itself, but that doesn't mean we should welcome when private entities censor.

In other words, because it isn't constitutionally protected doesn't mean I have to like it, and I certainly won't give them kudos for it. I'm not arguing the legality of it, you are and I'm not sure why. I suspect it's because you support this type of censorship.

Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by CydeWeys on Monday August 14, 2017 @06:24PM (#15013579)
You call it censorship, we call it the right to free association. A business shouldn't have to do business with Nazis if it doesn't want to.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by Clubber on Monday August 14, 2017 @10:10PM (#15014776)
Again, a straw man. I never said the government should force it. Do you support google's censorship? I mean what if they decided a liberal website was over the top and blocked their registration. Or an independent site critical of both Democrats and Republicans because they propose the entire system is corrupt? It works both (all three) ways.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by CydeWeys on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @11:28AM (#15019126)
You're making a slippery slope argument that I'm not finding at all convincing. The only domain name transfer that Google has refused, to my knowledge anyway, is this one. The Daily Stormer. A bunch of racist Nazis. It's a long leap from there to imagine Google refusing domain name registrations for mainstream political parties that fully half of the country subscribes to. I don't see it happening.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by Clubber on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @01:20PM (#15020249)
Oh my goodness, loss of liberty is a death from a thousand cuts. Do you think the PATRIOT act will ever be fully expired or repealed? No way. Do you think the NSA will ever be barred from collecting data on US citizens? Hell no. Those are liberties we've lost forever, and not just us, but our children and our children's children, in the last 20 years, because of complacency. Think of all the rights because of the drug war that will never end. We will lose plenty of others. It's a constant assault.

Can you even think of one government protected right we've gained in the last 20 years? Don't say pot, because we lost that right in the 1900s. As a citizen it is your duty to be diligent to protect your freedoms, for your self and future generations. The road to hell is paved with good intentions, and we're well down it.

Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by CydeWeys on Tuesday August 15, 2017 @04:58PM (#15022481)
You are again derailing the conversation by bringing up government actions, which are explicitly different than companies having the freedom to choose who they wish to do business with. Stick to the topic at hand! Companies cannot be forced to offer domain name registration services to Nazis if they do not want to. Forcing them to is a greater violation of liberty than allowing them the choice not to associate with Nazis.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by Clubber on Wednesday August 16, 2017 @02:41PM (#15030000)
No one said force but you. I am complaining about a problem and you are offering a solution, associating it with me, then criticizing it. Believe it or not, there is more than one way to solve a problem.

My solution was to have a public option registrar.

Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by trav4225 on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:04PM (#15011604)
Freedom of Speech is about freedom from tyranny of the state.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by jrs95 on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:08PM (#15011651)
Sadly, we don't really have much to ensure freedom from tyranny of the corporation. Especially since the owners of the corporations and the government are essentially the same people.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by trav4225 on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:12PM (#15011726)
Indeed, cronyism is the problem, and much of the blame falls on the voters who fail to hold their officials to account.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by jrs95 on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:38PM (#15012043)
Or even more so, the vast majority of people who don't bother to vote at all. Its less like a representative democracy, and more like a "democracy" that represents our collective failure.
Re:Google says it will ban neo-Nazi site after domain name s... by srinivgp on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:08PM (#15011655)
Equivocation. "the principle" points at different principles for different people. There are differences in which types of organizations we might wish to forbid from interfering with speech. It is absolutely coherent to believe in a principle which celebrates censorship by corporate entities but not by governmental entities.