News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Text Is Keeping Kids from Coding by Bartweiss on Monday August 14, 2017 @11:38AM (#15009434)
Honestly, I've got pretty mixed feelings about Scratch.

It's a very cool initiative that helps make basic programming more accessible, and I value it as a way to show kids "hey, programming exists and can be fun!"

But I've also had the misfortune of running events where kids use Scratch. These were 7th-9th graders who self-selected in, so up to a decade older than the target audience in this article. The results aren't exactly pretty, and they don't make me optimistic about giving Scratch to 5 year olds.

Scratch seems to have two major problems: awkward control flow, and a gridless environment.

- The first comes through as a large fraction of programs having broken or absurd loop and branch logic - often with a clear plan in mind, but terrible results. The difficulty of establishing hidden state encourages all sorts of ugly practices like handling a health bar by nesting the same code three times in conditionals to handle taking damage.

- The second is that where SpriteBox uses grids to establish clear coordinate systems and touching/overlapping/separate states, Scratch uses a continuous field. It creates awkward and unintuitive collision results, adds a layer of unfriendly abstraction (what does "forward 200" actually mean?), and makes drag-and-drop initialization a touchy and miserable experience, even for adults.

Overall, I think Scratch succeeds at reducing text, but fails to make abstraction and control feel approachable. It also introduces lots of novel headaches not present even in 'real' programming.

There are no comments on this comment yet.