News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nervous system manipulation by electromagnetic fields fro... by justinjlynn on Sunday August 13, 2017 @05:21PM (#15005007)
Please note that one does not have to prove anything in regards to the actual functionality claimed. The patent office is perfectly happy approving your anti-gravity device if it is novel. Keep this in mind (if you'll excuse the pun) when evaluating designs found there.
Re:Nervous system manipulation by electromagnetic fields fro... by didibus on Sunday August 13, 2017 @07:05PM (#15005480)
I always felt like patents shouldn't exist for ideas, but only for implementations. Having the idea, while sometime novel, is always easier then coming up with the implementation of it.
Re:Nervous system manipulation by electromagnetic fields fro... by gh02t on Monday August 14, 2017 @12:17AM (#15006549)
On the other hand, it can be hard to take an idea into production without some of the protection granted by a patent. Look at all the people who try to get their inventions manufactured in China, only to be beaten to market by a clone (not that a patent would help there, but ideally it would).

An inventor can't develop their idea if they can't talk to manufacturers without fear of getting ripped off.

Re:Nervous system manipulation by electromagnetic fields fro... by kutkloon7 on Monday August 14, 2017 @04:23AM (#15007265)
Well, one could argue that this is how competition works. If someone else can manufacture the same thing at lower cost, they deserve the market advantage.

Of course, this idea doesn't give credit to the inventors and benefits copycats. I just wanted to mention the idea.

Re:Nervous system manipulation by electromagnetic fields fro... by tempay on Monday August 14, 2017 @05:22AM (#15007445)
It depends if they can manufacture it at a lower cost or if they can just sell it at lower price as they don't have subsidise the time spent doing research and development. Not to mention subsidising past projects that didn't come to fruition.
Re:Nervous system manipulation by electromagnetic fields fro... by mschuster91 on Monday August 14, 2017 @09:46AM (#15008498)
> Of course, this idea doesn't give credit to the inventors and benefits copycats.

Well, let's take medicine with its huge R&D upfront cost as an example. Of course, given the recipe, the ingredients and the neccessary equipment, anyone can produce a medicine for dead cheap compared to the inventor, as they don't have to invest in R&D beforehand while the original inventor has to recoup the R&D cost and therefore has to call a price with significant markup over the manufacturing cost.

Re:Nervous system manipulation by electromagnetic fields fro... by nhaehnle on Monday August 14, 2017 @07:05AM (#15007823)
You haven't really addressed gh02t's point. The original (professed) intent of patents was to protect individual inventors.

If some other manufacturer finds a cheaper way to manufacture the same thing, they can get a patent on their improvement, and push for some licensing deal once they have that.

(This doesn't change the fact that the modern de facto practice of patents is pretty messed up. I'm just saying that there's a good idea behind it.)

Re:Nervous system manipulation by electromagnetic fields fro... by gh02t on Monday August 14, 2017 @06:34PM (#15013641)
I disagree. I'm talking about an inventor talking to a manufacturer (or engineering firm), the manufacturer saying "thanks for the idea, don't mind if we do" and then ripping the inventor off and not sharing the profit. That's not competition and it's not good for inventors, because sharing your idea is inherently part of the process of taking it to market.

IMO, fair competition comes into play after the inventor has developed their product into something ready for production, otherwise the incentive to invent will disappear. Whether they then deserve a temporary monopoly to recover their development costs is up for debate I guess, but I'm talking about shielding inventors from getting robbed of their ideas.

Re:Nervous system manipulation by electromagnetic fields fro... by tacostakohashi on Monday August 14, 2017 @07:08AM (#15007833)
If someone else can manufacture the same thing at lower cost, then the inventor / patent holder is going to want to outsource their production to the lowest cost producer.

The lowest cost producer does indeed enjoy a market advantage in the market for manufacturing.

Re:Nervous system manipulation by electromagnetic fields fro... by gh02t on Monday August 14, 2017 @08:56PM (#15014454)
Want to, sure. But you usually sign a contract, you can't just change.
Re:Nervous system manipulation by electromagnetic fields fro... by everheardofc on Monday August 14, 2017 @06:02AM (#15007588)
Software patents shouldn't exist, unless the sourcecode that the patent is protecting is released under a permissive license or equivalent. Having both copyright and patent protections at the same time is insane. Patents have a reasonable duration. With copyright the duration is basically infnite for everyone even though only a minority of companies actually care about it.
Re:Nervous system manipulation by electromagnetic fields fro... by posterboy on Monday August 14, 2017 @03:41AM (#15007146)
> is always easier then coming up with the implementation of it.

along that line of reasoning, making claims is easier than proving them, always. It's not always the case though, any given prime factorization is easy to prove but hard to propose.

Re:Nervous system manipulation by electromagnetic fields fro... by vqc on Sunday August 13, 2017 @11:20PM (#15006414)
Isn't this what the enablement and written description requirements are for?
Re:Nervous system manipulation by electromagnetic fields fro... by naasking on Monday August 14, 2017 @07:54AM (#15008017)
> I always felt like patents shouldn't exist for ideas, but only for implementations

That's how it works. You patent the mechanism of achieving an end given some input, not the idea of it.

Re:Nervous system manipulation by electromagnetic fields fro... by dboreham on Sunday August 13, 2017 @06:23PM (#15005282)
Is that totally true? I had always heard that for example applications for perpetual motion machines would always be denied. Perhaps that was the U.K. Patent Office? The USPTO really allows on the face impossible inventions??
Re:Nervous system manipulation by electromagnetic fields fro... by jacobolus on Sunday August 13, 2017 @06:39PM (#15005366)
Wikipedia:

Proposals for such inoperable machines have become so common that the United States Patent and Trademark Office (USPTO) has made an official policy of refusing to grant patents for perpetual motion machines without a working model. The USPTO Manual of Patent Examining Practice states:

> With the exception of cases involving perpetual motion, a model is not ordinarily required by the Office to demonstrate the operability of a device. If operability of a device is questioned, the applicant must establish it to the satisfaction of the examiner, but he or she may choose his or her own way of so doing.[24]

And, further, that:

> A rejection [of a patent application] on the ground of lack of utility includes the more specific grounds of inoperativeness, involving perpetual motion. A rejection under 35 U.S.C. 101 for lack of utility should not be based on grounds that the invention is frivolous, fraudulent or against public policy.[25]

The filing of a patent application is a clerical task, and the USPTO will not refuse filings for perpetual motion machines; the application will be filed and then most probably rejected by the patent examiner, after he has done a formal examination.[26] Even if a patent is granted, it does not mean that the invention actually works, it just means that the examiner believes that it works, or was unable to figure out why it would not work.[26]

The USPTO maintains a collection of Perpetual Motion Gimmicks.

Re:Nervous system manipulation by electromagnetic fields fro... by dboreham on Monday August 14, 2017 @09:53AM (#15008533)
Ok thanks so the parent was incorrect: the USPTO will not grant a patent on an anti-gravity machine.
Re:Nervous system manipulation by electromagnetic fields fro... by dom0 on Sunday August 13, 2017 @06:39PM (#15005367)
Re:Nervous system manipulation by electromagnetic fields fro... by acrefoot on Monday August 14, 2017 @02:13AM (#15006851)
It might slip through the USPTO, but it would be a pretty flimsy patent, as it wouldn't pass the test for enablement. At least, that's my understanding when I was consulting our lawyers for a provisional patent.

https://www.uspto.gov/web/offices/pac/mpep/s2164.html

Re:Nervous system manipulation by electromagnetic fields fro... by vqc on Sunday August 13, 2017 @08:40PM (#15005919)
W/r/t anti-gravity, what about written description and the enablement requirements?
Re:Nervous system manipulation by electromagnetic fields fro... by CodeTheInternet on Monday August 14, 2017 @12:42PM (#15010084)
We need better patent clerks like we did at the turn of last century.